Critics are often annoying; they are often too caught up in looking intellectual or cool, plus they forget their opinion is just that – an opinion, not truth.

I once read a critic slaming ‘Day of the Doctor’ while praising ’42’ and ‘Mummy on the…[Read more]

Lots of New-Who dislikes River because of…[Read more]

@Timeloop Yes I saw that interview with Moffat and I also saw your earlier post re “The End of Time” when you’d re-checked that Gallifrey is indeed burning on-screen.

The thing is, Moffat’s perspective doesn’t settle the question for me. Once you have…[Read more]

The Telegraph is one of the broadsheets here in the UK – that is not a tabloid like The Sun. A bit like The Times, although ironically that paper is owned by Rupert Murdoch who also owns The Sun.  It has […]

(I dont […]

but Susan coining the acronym is canon

@Lula and @Shazzbot – ever since we found out that the Time Lords also call them tardis’s, I’ve presumed that Susan made up the acronym in English. She invented the English […]

Myself and @MTGradwell (hello, btw) had a detailed discussion on this over on the G blog.

His point was that the stories (as transmitted on tv) remain as they are (ie no change […]

Continuity error?  Timey-wimey?   I’m not nit-picking, but Susan coining the acronym is canon, so…

Well, if we start looking for continuity errors like that, we’d probably find thousands.  Admittedly, […]

River – this could be the end for River post SitL (and what a beautiful end!) but there’s plenty of scope to bring her back (a pre SitL version) if the writers think there’s a good […]

I am looking very much forward to your thoughts on the episode =))

I have been sent a link to the 4 versions of Tennant’s “I don’t want to go” by another Craig who is, of course, unable to sign up at the moment. I hope he will join us after […]

It’s also very easy to accommodate it thro @Bluesqueakpip‘s theory that the regenerations get more complicated when you get into double figs, or maybe the Dr just being older and […]

Indeed. Many Buffy fans on here – and in fact, NuWho was influenced by Buffy.

(I really mean it–Buffy is in my top 5 of favorite dramas.)

This is true of all right-thinking people.

A grave for Time Lords….maybe that is exactly what Trenzalore is. And if it was, I guess that would be a place “you should never go” if you were […]

I am more interested in what Trenzalore is…all we know is that it is the place where people must speak the […]

not

even

look.

Last chance.

@Lula we are on the same page with River. I refuse to believe that she is a projection. And I want/demand (! *stomps foot) a propper explanation. I have a feeling this […]

@Lula Because Americans, particularly southerners, do this–we’ll talk to anyone,  anytime, any reason. I’ve been told a […]

This is not a spoiler but is about spoilers

Doctor Who Tv has closed all comments until 18 May. Confirmed that the final ep has been sent out. Moffatt will be […]

The question standing is how could they have let that happen?

Weird, because their website is firmly saying ‘Monday 20th’.

Oh, yes, if they’d sent it me I’d be watching it right now. Of course I would. As you say, anyone would.

But it must be so frustrating to […]

I’m going to have to figure out how to get Tumblr Saviour too although I don’t follow a tonne of Doctor Who blogs over there as I tend to […]

Are you sure she doesn’t mean ‘dispatched on Friday midnight’? Because they do sometimes send it out the postal day before official release, so that it arrives on release day. They did that with the Harry […]

What a fascinating idea about the painting – I rather hope you are right. It would be a nice circle.

But, alas, I think you have rather more confidence in SM than I do.

<a href='http://www.thedoctorwhoforum.com/members/blenkinsopthebrave/&#039; […]

<a href='http://www.thedoctorwhoforum.com/members/thedoctordude/&#039; […]

You are spoilt by BBC America (and I don’t mean it in the “spoiler” sense!) with the re-runs, the shows dedicated to […]

…You know you could be reconstructed by the hole you’ve left behind,’ very intriguing.  Reconstructed by Clara?  Of course.

Hmmm, intriguing. Or what about… Clara IS the […]

Spoiler discussion…………..

*****************************

I read that about the previews earlier but never made that connect. I am all kinds of excited at that […]

@Lula yup, I’m on EST too. John Barrowman […]

If I were him, I’d go at the end of the Anniversary Special – there will […]

At the time of the Fifth series there was a massive amount of speculation that he was to return because of the symbols you mention. False entries on IMDB even […]

Unhappy people tell tales.

Equally, though, people claim there has been a […]