@JimTheFish

On re reading this, I wanted to make an extra point, although I cant edit for some reason.

The description of the Thals also shows that the show included serious points for adults and or […]

@JimTheFish

I thought the rationale at the time was that the Thals have, after their own cycle of genetic mutation combined with the historical memory of the global thermonuclear war, essentially become firm […]

@JimTheFish

As ever, there’s little in your post and analysis I would actually disagree with. Your explanation that the Older foes form a welcome break between the more psychologically scary AG elements […]

@ScaryB

I never know quite how much I should write. My point with the %’s is that RTD/SM have managed to find quite a lot of screen time to use BG foes. You can’t therefore argue that there isn’t screen time to […]

@ScaryB

I hadn’t thought about it until today when I saw the news, but it just had to be didn’t it ?

The pictures look good. This and the length suggests we have every chance of seeing something […]

@JimTheFish @JanetteB

Now that’s a challenge. I’d suggest one of Terror of the Vervoids, Revelation of the Daleks or Vengence on Varos

(it will be a shame to loose Alexei Sale, but I’m afraid it is a […]

Well done. Very believable. I see you have the original River prototype on her way as well 🙂

Nick

@JimTheFish

I understand where RTD and SM are coming from as former fans. They have a difficult call to make as show runners. Whilst there is undoubtedly far too many BG ARSEs out there, I think on balance they […]

@Shazzbot

I’m not so sure that ending the 12 regenerations limit (13 Doctors) has got to go in quite the same way you think. You can actually argue that when River gave the Doctor her remaining Artron energy he […]

@JimTheFish

I’m not so sure that I am against changing past continuity at all and I think that AG Who has been far too conservative by bringing back and reusing BG Who foes (too often and far worse far given […]

@Bluesqueakpip

Fantastic. I even think I understand it (well maybe).

I think fixed points are a matter of perspective as much as anything else, which is a subtly different way at looking at your Rume 1 and […]

@HTPBDET @Shazzbot

Re the Tardis show

This originally came out of a point I raise which questioned why the Doctors ability to steer the Tardis in the AG-SM era hd mkedly improved than in earlier series (both […]

@HTPBDET

SM story arc/arcs

Yes I actually believe he will tie them all together before he goes. We may well be in for a shock if he does as I think he’s probably playing a long game he had in his mind at the […]

@Shazzbot @HTPBDET

I agree of course, but is your description entirely correct description. The “fall of 11” as dropped in quite a while back, but we still don’t know what it exactly means. His narrative is ? […]