• janetteB replied to the topic Flatline

    @dentarthurdent One of the quibbles i have with the Moffat era is the depiction of Churchill as being a kindly leader. I don’t share that view of Churchill. My mother certainly did, having gone through the war being drip fed pro British propaganda. She did not even see him as the person who was willing to sell out Australia, not allowing theĀ …[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Flatline

    @dentarthurdent Yes. The problem with heavy handed moralising is that you loose the people you won over with the message in the story even if they are totally “on board” they will be offended because they feel as though they are being patronised and if they don’t agree they might have been influenced but the moment they realise that they will turn…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Flatline

    @dentarthurdent Great reviews, both of them. I must have read the review a year ago but really enjoyed reading it again. It is an excellent episode, great characters, great story, great dialogue. The concept of the Doctor being trapped in a tiny Tardis is unique as are the 2d “monsters.” Lots of original ideas. Rigsy is a well written character…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic The Winchester

    Sorry to hear about the fires. So terrible, heartbreaking and infuriating because this should not be happening, not like this. I hope that you are OK @nerys.

    cheers

    Janette

  • janetteB replied to the topic Mummy on the Orient Express

    @dentarthurdent Though the Doctor worked for UNIT he was always anti military, and continually ribbed the Brigadier for his “five rounds rapid” approach to problems. The Doctor was always a little anarchic but also clever, using “science” (inverted commas because science in Dr Who isn’t always scientific) rather than brute force, as per the…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Mummy on the Orient Express

    Was pondering the episode while prepping dinner. Soldiers are very much a theme of this series. In Into the Dalek the Doctor rejects Journey Blue because while she might be a very nice person she is a soldier. Soldiers are not evil but they obey without question which makes them easily manipulated by evil. The Mummy is simply following orders, a…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Mummy on the Orient Express

    @dentarthurdent Yes this is a cracker of an episode. It is well written and beautifully designed. The tension between the Doctor and Clara is perfectly balanced. I think he is able to relate to Perkins and Moorehouse because they are scientists at work. It isn’t a personal interaction. Love the touch with the jelly babies. The twenties look suits…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Kill the Moon

    @dentarthurdent you are braver than me. Agreed many episodes improve on second watch. I did not particularly like Time Heist the first time I watched it but now really enjoy it. I have no intention of ever giving Kill the Moon a second chance however. I don’t think it has a single redeeming quality.

    Regarding subconscious memory, I often find…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Time Heist

    @dentarthurdent Another enjoyable review.. I was not overly enamoured of Time Heist the first time I watched it, (perhaps because it follows Listen), but it has really grown on me on re watches. It is an excellent episode in most aspects though the skull collapsing because the brain is melted does bother me because that would not happen. (For the…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    @dentarthurdent. I am getting a bit excited about the anniversary specials too. We recently re-watched a few RTD episodes just as a reminder of his show runner/writing style. Also I watched Years and Years which is basically a non sci fi 6 episode version of Turn Left. I did have a sneak look at the trailers and they however somewhat dampened…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    @blenkinsopthebrave I had not seen the Regency pics so went hunting at once. Nice costumes. I do like it when the Doctor and Companion dress for the period. I’m guessing that when not going to period times the Doctor will have a iconic outfit, or how could fans cosplay him?

    Only six months now, (roughly) to wait for the 60th…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    @winston I it is cold and dreary here. I am looking out at the garden which is in need of pruning and weeding and trying to muster the energy to get out there and overcome my aversion to the cold and damp. So I am envying you the warm weather but not the mosquitos. Those I think anyone can do without.

    I like the Guardian fantasy house hunt and…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    I was trying to asses the costume and not the Doctor hence listing Capaldi’s amongst the fails. I always felt that they did not “nail” it and the stary jumper was up there with the question marks. (or should I say down there?) Capaldi is one of my absolute favourite Doctors though. Likewise I liked Whitaker’s costume but was not a massive fan of…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Listen

    @dentarthurdent. Another enjoyable review. Thank you.

    One of the best episodes of AGWho and I can’t think of an old Who episode that was better. It is one of my “go to” episodes.

    Cheers

    Janette

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    @dentarthurdent, @blenkisnopthebrave and @devislishrobby

    We had a round table family discussion last night about the costumes and divided them into three catagories, the good, the bad and the indifferent.

    The Bad, (not necessarily in worst to least bad order) Colin Baker, Peter Davison, Ecclestone and Capaldi, the indifferent, Tennant, the Good,…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    there could be a costume spoiler in there so mods please note and move if you consider it to a more appropriate thread.

     

  • janetteB replied to the topic Dr Who News (5)

    Some Dr Who whimsy to bring a smile to the face today and hopefully inspire some discussion.

    I have to rush off to record a podcast but when I get back I will be compiling my own list as I agree with some but certainly not all of this one.

    Cheers

    Janette

  • janetteB replied to the topic Robot of Sherwood

    @dentarthurdent I was looking forward to your review of Robot of Sherwood. It is a fun episode, the kind that cheers me up if I feel a bit down, and has a lovely meta line at the end but it has that one glaring fault, the golden arrow. It does not work in a “real world” sense but nor does it work as fantasy. It just doesn’t work which is a shame…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic Into the Dalek

    @dentarthurdent Back in the long distant days of 1963, and what a year it was.. it was considered too risque to have a young woman travelling alone with and old man in a cosy police box so they made her his granddaughter. It was done for convenience sake and many fans have questioned the relationship. It seems that RTD and the Moff both decided…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic BBC Approved Spoilers

    BBC APPROVED SPOILERS...

  • Load More