Yep good answer on the prisoner question  thx!

ekstroem
Participant
!– .bbp-reply-author —

Amazing episode… Totally mind blowing!

One thing with Clara tho, did I just totally miss that or did they not explain why the Tardis doesn’t like […]

Hey that was an amazing episode, really pleased with the writing in that 🙂    Clara flashbacks such as getting the first doctor to pick the correct tardis was simply inspired 🙂

Oh and I was in-the-ballpark […]

HaveYouFedTheFish
Participant
!– .bbp-reply-author —

Aaaaand another inconsistency this episode raises: How could the Eye of Harmony – an inherently non renewable power source, actually inside and […]

Im sticking with my theory that Clara is impossible and she causes something impossible each episode and that will in time reveal her true nature.  My best guess is a living human paradox which has the effect of a […]

Therefore its not a paradox and although it’s not impossible Clara willed a remote into being, that’s not necessary for the plot to work.

Technically that means every iteration of the loop creates an extra […]

Oh and let me take this a bit further—Clara (isnt there a big friendly button)

And sure enough, There existed a big friendly button—

Would it have been there if she hadnt willed it.     I think not.

Once again the idea for the ultimate solution was a gentle push from Clara: she was the one to first mention the need for a big red button. She planted the idea in the Doctor’s mind and the TARDIS and the Dr ran […]

Well, Since we are talking shows (and I feel the same as Lula, tv is so good who needs movies?) , I confess here and now. I havnt watched Madmen or Breaking Bad 🙁   YET        I forgot my whole family loves […]

With that noted, Im sure some really good stuff is in the works 🙂

badwolf99
Participant
!– .bbp-reply-author —

Central Theme, Alot of cool posts. Well it keeps coming back to this for me. ( Clara can do impossible things

Someone ponted out it she is like Mary […]

WhoHar
Participant
!– .bbp-reply-author —

@Lula

There is a general level of twattery on the Guardian blog now which is disappointing.

I too am very anti the anti-American comments which I find to be […]

Central Theme, Alot of cool posts. Well it keeps coming back to this for me. ( Clara can do impossible things 🙂

Someone ponted out it she is like Mary Poppins :), very astute and accurate as well. A sci-fy […]

thedoctordude
Participant
!– .bbp-reply-author —

@Badwolf99 I think that’s a very interesting idea that the universe has recreated her three times. If the universe recreated her, that would explain how […]

Shazzbot,  Well we know her abilities are real.   When she dies (more like a displacement for her) ,  I think the universe recreates her complete with a background, and the Doctor has investigated her current […]

Yep Bluesqueak, Her power is real and my original desire to open debate on  ;), why and how, thats going to be open to debate, a paradox, a storyteller, memories of the doctor manifesting in her,  some subset all […]

You get it perfectly 🙂   Exactly, wonderfully perfect!!!! Thx,  Yeah Im thinking, thats another thing really worrying the Doctor, A Paradox that cant die or be fixed because the universe wont let it. Well its […]

Yes interesting points to bring up, Clara is like an Empty-child, so maybe that ties in, I think she is the hero (so far) and its her ability to cause impossible things to happen that is scaring and amazing the […]

Maybe, If so she is a very unique paradox. Im thinking of Capt. Jack being a fixed point in time, and so, he couldnt die. She may be many fixed points (a nexus as it were) with the added ability that she can […]