Forum Replies Created

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #75012

    In New Dr Who the companions (not including people like Mickey and Captain Jack) ranked have to be.

    1. Clara Oswald. She was funny, smart, and didn’t completely fall for the Doctor.

    2. Amy Pond. Because she was so Amy. So many companions acted different around the Doctor, but Amy acted the same whether she was in Venice or Mars.

    3. Bill Potts. Not everyone liked her but I found her to be lively and fun to be around.

    4. Graham O’Brien. He was really sweet to Ryan who wasn’t always the same back and after Grace died I’m impressed that he didn’t take his grief out on the Doctor.

    5. Dan Lewis. He was great and really kind, but he felt quite 1 sided.

    6. Martha Jones. She kind of deserves to be higher up, but I found her obsession a little needy, although when she marries Micky that is epic.

    7. Yaz Khan. She was nice enough and the stuff with the Doctor was good, but I thought there wasn’t a lot of backstory there.

    8. Rose Tyler. She annoyed me. Dyed blonde hair, hoop earrings, blinding white teeth. Why does everyone love her? I was sad when she went, but I enjoyed Martha far more.

    9. Donna. She was theĀ worst. Always criticising, always complaining, always being frankly offensive. Why oh why did the Dr put up with her? I know Catherine Tate is most people’s favourite, but she is so irritating.

    #74975

    In the scene in which the Doctor and Donna are trapped in the Toymaker’s I don’t know – is it a maze or something? – I think it felt like we were back in the previous episode. While not entirely similar, and of course Dr Who does this frequently, with the Empty Child and 42 as well as various others, two episodes in a row with a quick-paced chase in which the Doctor is sometimes separated from companion felt like a bit much. However, I enjoyed it and the Giggle is one of the best episodes to date in my opinion.

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)