[janisthorns @replies]

the Valeyard is an amalgamation of all 13–so he can influence all the Doctors

[janisthorns @replies]

‘no living creature can speak falsely or fail to answer’

the Doctor did not answer, the GI asked over and over–he refused–so who has to ask so that “no living creature can speak fasely of fail to  answer”  and maybe the question was not to just open the tomb–maybe the question is really still to come

[janisthorns @replies]

PS I own a pet shop in Oregon now, work 7 days a week, and still am weedeling my way for a week in London

[janisthorns @replies]

I was about 12 (1975)  when I started watching–in rural West Virginia–eastern US–not sure where in the world the rest of you are from–but I thought I was the only one on earth watching this show–had no idea what it was but loved it.  PBS was patchy with broadcasts.  When I saw an episode with another Doctor (Tom Baker was THE Doctor for me) I was confused and mad– I remember being upset with nobody to talk to! I began to piece together the idea of  regenerations–but–why did nobody understand my babble about this concept.  It was lonely–those of you with a society of people who know about Who –lucky you.

I went on to love a lot of sci-fi and have even been an math and science teacher in public school.  I missed all of 5-6-7 in the 80s and 90s and have now started to go back and watch.  I was thrilled to see Who back after the gap.  It is a whole rebirth of interest for old and a lot of new fans.   It is just such a positive beacon. Moffett is resurrecting, refreshing  and incorporating old ideas.  But, in a way you don’t have to know 50 years of history to enjoy–but it helps.  And Matt Smith is amazing.

I am happy to chat with my people.

Anyone going to London in November?  I am recruiting a US to London party.  I am in Oregon now (not WVa, but have one recruit attending from WVa).

remember–

“name The Doctor, rank Doctor, intention fun”

this will be fun

 

 

 

 

[janisthorns @replies]

I think Hurt is the last incarnation–the Doctor Shadow self–the Valeyard–Clara just allowed him to meet him–he (11) knew he (13) was there (they are all him, all there)–13 influenced all those bad Doctor decisions throughout time.   And 13 broke the promise of the name he chose “The Doctor”–I think Moffett is beginning a new thread (well, old thread picked up).  And Hurt will be in the 50th as 13–and we still have the pleasure of not knowing 12.  As the last incarnation he gets over shadowed by doubt–indecision–all the bad creeps up.

The Silence want him dead–because of the belief they “will fall” if he answers the question–he didn’t–but did River?  He already wiped them (The Silence) out (more or less) so nothing much we know of happened when he did go to Trenzalore–thus the Silence thread (for now) is finished–to start the new one.

???

 

 

[janisthorns @replies]

hi– I am new to on-line chatting–I have been with Who since I was 12 years old (Yes, I am 50 (too) )-

Do we have the Valeyard?  Has to be between 12-13.  11 said he “broke the promise”,  they are calling him the Doctor but he is the Valeyard.

 

Also–anyone going to London In November??–I am–would like company (nobody I can find local(Oregon)).

 

 

[Author]

Posts