@Bluesqueakpip @nick @shazzbot @ScaryB

 I think it is important to work out about whom we are speaking.

Who are the AG companions?

For RTD,  is it Rose, Martha and Donna? Or that group plus Adam, Mickey, […]

@Nick

harder to reuse without repeating essentially the same story

I just don’t understand how that doesn’t also apply to creatures with an “agenda”,  eg if it’s the daleks then they want to take over and […]

@Bluesqueakpip Excellent analysis as ever, hope you’ve cooled down a bit. (Come up to the far  north, we’re struggling to hit 20 here)

@Nick –

For me the other interesting question is why RTD and SM chose to […]

I think if this is to be a Blog, we need someone to clearly state a position to start off. Potentially – what they see the differences as, and whether they are a source of concern to them. As @nick has expressed […]

@Nick, @bluesqueakpip, @PhaseShift,@JimTheFish ,@Shazzbot and @everyone else!
 Not much time today – but just to throw a few bones into the pack…so to speak 🙂

Agenda

I cannot think of a single BG […]

@Phaseshift Sorry, meant to comment on your idea re Weeping Angels being like psycopathic killers – that’s neat. Also that we may not know everything about them yet – scope for new story with them.

@Nick Was it […]

@nick

Well it’s always good to clarify these points, and in my absence, @JimTheFish and @bluesqueakpip have covered most of the points I would have raised.

The comparison with serial killers is a good one […]

@Nick

Re all the AG stories about the end of earth/universe/all of time and space etc, and why don’t we see an effect of that after wards… apart from my response above re it’s not that kind of show – what […]

@Shazzbot First rule of this forum is that given enough time we will ALWAYS ramble 😉 But we usually ramble back on topic sooner or later!

And I do think much of @Nick‘s problems with the AG show is to do with […]

building a food warehouse (multiple food sources are better than one but I see no plan here – more opportunism).

@Nick – general question: have you ever built anything? Or kept pets? Or had a vegetable garden?

😉

@Nick – if you mean that the Angels don’t match Maslow’s Hierarchy of needs, no – they don’t. They’re aliens.

That said, they are capable of planning and building the equivalent of a food warehouse. They’re […]

@Nick

Agenda
I’m not sure why this word causes such a problem

I suspect it’s because you’re using it to mean ‘political/military agenda’ and ‘formal plan’ – and it doesn’t necessarily mean that. It means […]