Forum Replies Created

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #21958
    OCalTh3Irish @replies

    @denvaldron I feel like youre looking for too many things wrong in the episode.  youre reading in to it too much.  The Moment opened all three portals on purpose, at exactly the points she wanted to, by looking into the Doctor’s timeline.  We know she can do that because thats how she explains looking like Rose.  As for what The Moment can do, you really dont need to know, you just really want to know.  Yes its done a lot to help explain in stories but I dont think its completely necessary.  I actually found it made the Moment more terrifying because as far as we know it could be capable of anything.  Hurt tells us its “the most dangerous weapon in the universe”  and we know it destroys Gallifrey, do we really need to know the specifics? I dont think so.  It wouldve been nice to know but we werent told so i just kinda ran with it cause i wanted to enjoy the special.  as for how elizabeth knew the plan, i just assumed she was cunning enough to use subtle ways of gleening info about the attack plan by not just being told but by observing and putting the pieces together herself.  All in all, just enjoy the show man.  Its never been about being accurate in every way its just meant to be enjoyable 🙂

     

    #21956
    OCalTh3Irish @replies

    My theory is that at Trenzalore the Doctor will try to bring Gallifrey back but the Silence will try to stop him.  at some point he can get an army of Timelords out to help fight off the Silence and ends up sacrificing himself in the process.  however, as he is dying he realizes that he won’t be able to bring back Gallifrey on Trenzalore so he picks out one of them (Peter Capaldi) who has shown promise throughout the episode and answers the question “Doctor who?” to close them off in the painting “Gallifrey Falls No More” and sets an interactive interface of himself (the Tom Baker cameo in DOTD) and appoints Capaldi as the new doctor and is buried at Trenzalore leaving Capaldi with a different Tardis.  It has been implied before that a timelord only has 12 versions and with the Warrior doctor smith is the 12th, hence he has no more re generations.  and Capaldi is a different timelord adopting the name of The Doctor and rebooting the story line that way.  Probably full of plot holes i know but this is what I’ve thought through so far.

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)