@Missy    To be fair, had River not firmly believed that Smith Doc was in his last possible incarnation, I think she would have guessed fairly quickly who the Doctor was. But sometimes a very strong preconception can make the truth practically impossible to see.

@joamdalf     Personally, if I met someone who seemed clever enough but freely said a…[Read more]

@joamdalf   It is almost impossible to define the Doctor but there are some things about him that never change. He does not have a weapon, only his huge brain ,quick wit, bravado and sometimes a sonic screwdriver or sunglasses. He always seems to have a plan to right a wrong or an injustice. He can be cranky but rarely cruel or mean.When e…[Read more]

@joamdalf

That’s a surprisingly hard question! I suppose in a way you know he’s the doctor as he has to defeat some alien threat and that is generally what the doctor does. In other words he has to prove to everyone that he can be the doctor by defeating the monsters!

If you want to watch some episodes I recommend watching any of the doctors…[Read more]

@puroandson

That’s because you have such excellent tast. As do we all. *big grin*

@joamdalf

Hello Joam, I will be interested in hearing all the replies to your request.
As for me, you simply know it’s the Doctor, ( which is no help at all) although River didn’t. *grin*

Cheers,

Missy