@bluesqueakpip Yes, there was not a new haircut or a new suit, he was wearing a tux.

@lisa loving the Tom Baker theory

@purofilion What do you think?

Any ideas?

After watching this two-part episode again I am positive River was merely uploaded and CAL is Clara.  I don’t think River’s Doctor is Smith alone, I truly believe it’s a later Doctor, possibly the current Doctor.  I believe Tasha Lem is River reaching out from the Library through another mainframe.  Tasha does mean birthday and Lem means owned by…[Read more]

Ellen Ripley? Have never seen the movies, so I can’t comment on the validity of that.

I have yet to try the SF test, but I did find a fun site that gives a Myers-Briggs type for each Doctor.  I can’t seem to cut and paste on this site or I would paste the link.  This is the only site my paste button doesn’t work on?  This forum demands I use the Ctrl button to paste, but it’s a tablet without that option.  I will have to type it…[Read more]

@purofilion Good to know, I was concerned.  Some of my ideas center around Smith not being River’s Doctor, considering my theories in the above comment #40818.  Smith’s Doctor did say he was going to the Singing Towers with her that night, but like in the above comment, he was not sporting a new haircut or new suit.  The 11th did think it was an…[Read more]

SPOILER, SPOILER, SPOILER...

@Lula Also loved this episode.  I think it was a very poignant and moving episode and in my top ten.

Critics are often annoying; they are often too caught up in looking intellectual or cool, plus they forget their opinion is just that – an opinion, not truth.

I once read a critic slaming ‘Day of the Doctor’ while praising ’42’ and ‘Mummy on the…[Read more]

SPOILER, SPOILER, SPOILER...

SPOILER, SPOILER, SPOILER...

@ardaraith @Bluesqueakpip I think the weight of the statement “only one time that I could” and how much grievance River is clearly going through reminding him, is due to his name being the password, or key, to bringing back the Time Lords in TtotD. He was supposed to die in the Time War, the Time War that would kill millions and turn the town of…[Read more]

Tasha Lem could very well be River, actually, I am almost positive that she is. The “rocking the new body” reference does not change that for me.  River and the Doctor meet out of order, as we know.   If it is a regeneration of River, then I would assume it took place after the little girl in spacesuit regeneration.  We never see her turn into Me…[Read more]

@Bluesqueakpip @ThePapalMainframe @janetteB I would love to see or read a spin off of Amy and Rory in the 1930s.  What a great idea.

Rory was always a nurse, except in his dream during ‘Amy’s Choice’ where he fancies himself a Doctor….with really bad hair.

SPOILER, SPOILER, SPOILER...

Sorry, I meant to write @Bluesqueakpip

SPOILER, SPOILER, SPOILER...

@purofilion Thank you!  This was very useful and helpful info.  🙂