• Mudlark replied to the topic Heaven Sent

    Nit-pick corner.

    @puroandson  @teddybear  You were discussing the survival properties of organic materials such as wood, and my professional opinion was sought.

    In the very long term, of course, on a geologically active planet with an atmosphere, nothing would survive in its original form.  In the course of several billion years mountains cou…[Read more]

  • tardigrade replied to the topic Heaven Sent

    @teddybear

    Another inconsistency: He throws the stool into the water each time, but though there are billions of skulls, there are not billions of rotting stools in the water.

    I’d think the stools would rot away to effectively nothing in hundreds of years if they aren’t reset as part of the room. So I wouldn’t expect to see billions, but there wo…[Read more]

  • Ericam replied to the topic Heaven Sent

    @teddybear    I never would have thought of that. LOL that’s awesome!

    @bendubz11   That makes since though, but the stool was no longer in the room so would the stool disappear even if it was no longer in the room. I guess we will never know….

  • bendubz11 replied to the topic Heaven Sent

    @teddybear The skulls are all CapDoc so do not reset, as they are not part of any room. The stool does because it is a part of that room

  • Mudlark replied to the topic Heaven Sent

    @teddybear   Hello and welcome to the forum.

    The confession dial clearly isn’t a Last Will and Testament as we understand it, nor a straightforward confession. As far as I can make out from the clues we have been given, it is more like a complete and continuously updated record of the Doctor’s life as experienced in his conscious and u…[Read more]