Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
16 July 2015 at 13:03 #41242
@purofilion Twisting facts is not a way to do research and might led to an unreasonable and confusing work.
I know the fact that the doctor may not have any beliefs what so ever, I accept that fact with an open mind, heart and arms.
But what I am trying to do is expand the this single thing about our dear doctor and say “could this happen ?”
“why” “why not” putting in mind what happened before and after the events of the time skip. that’s all.
16 July 2015 at 10:58 #41239@purofilion What do you think of my theory ?
16 July 2015 at 10:27 #41236@purofillion
ohh questions, I like them 😉
Before I begin, let me explain something, my major is English literature, and I am doing my masters degree, my aim is to do it in
something modern and interesting, the doctor’s personality and behavior. hence why I ask too many question.
I apologies to you guys for not clarifying this earlier, and I want to thank @jimthefish, @bluesqueakpip, and you for being
patient with me, and I apologies for asking too many annoying questions.
1- As far as I believe, we don’t have any proof if the doctor is an atheist or has a sense of religion, that’s my personal opinion.
Let me explain.
In popular fiction, whatever the medium is, there is something called a time skip, those who watch anime know what I mean.
A time skip is an amount of time between two parts of the story. It is used to skip to the next part of the story, instead
of having to go through the actual time, unless the writer tells us everything that happen in between that period, it is left to our
imagination.
My theory here is that the Doctor who series has been going through several time skips, and will continue to do so because
of the nature of the show. As many of you know there are a number of adventures that happen in between the episodes, adventures
that we never hear about, what’s stopping us from believing that are other adventures that the doctor is not telling us ?
What’s stopping us from believing that those adventures affected the doctor’s personality ?
You might say the next episode, but about the amount of time that we have after that episode and before the next episode ?
You might also ask, what about the other series ?
They are based not based on time travel and does not have the same features of the doctor who show, the fact that he tells us
those adventures gives us the right to imagine anything.
2- I don’t know. bluesqueakpip said the same thing, but I really don’t know. But when I say beast I do mean beast.
3- this:
http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_Beast_%28The_Impossible_Planet%29
4- I think he has what it takes.
He might be a mixture between Smith and Capadli. He played Khan and Sherlock, so he has the ability to play the doctor.
5- the 9th, 10th, 11th, and 12th
The 9th for his pain and for being the one after the time war, the 10th for his seance of humor and his ability to shift between serious and
funny, the 11th for his personality all around, and for his entire story, the fact that he there were two season that focus on his name makes
his adventures an odyssey rather then just adventures. The 12th for simply being an enigma
16 July 2015 at 00:46 #41222@blueswueakpipe
ahh, that makes seance know, thanks 🙂 😀
16 July 2015 at 00:10 #41220No, I’m using a laptop why ?
About question 1:
I heard that one of the doctor’s incarnation, I think the second, use to pray to a god that the time lords pray to, that was either
a prose or an audio adventure.
Is that true ?
and if it is, is it canon ?
and by canon
I mean are the events that happen in the comics and prose are in the same universe of the show ?
And are the events that happen there happen to the same doctor that is on the show, or is he
another version of him ?
About question 3:
Wasn’t the war doctor the 8th doctor ?
15 July 2015 at 23:30 #41218As for question 1:
What about the time when the 11th doctor mentioned the best he referees to him simply as the devil ?
As for question 3:
What does Hurt have to do with this ?
he was the 8th doctor, and he appeared with the 10th and 11th, and it wasn’t the first time where three incarnations of
the doctor appeared together.
As for question 4:
But do you think he will make a good doctor ?
15 July 2015 at 22:38 #41216@purofilion
Hi guys 🙂
I have four questions I want to ask you:
1- Is the doctor considered an atheist ?
I know that we talked about this issue, but this is the last one, I promise.
2- How long do you think Peter Capaldi will last as the doctor ?
3- Who would you like the 13th doctor to be ?
4- Do you think that Benedict Cumberbatceh will make a good doctor ?
12 July 2015 at 14:12 #41136@jimthefish I’m referring to the Satan pit episode and the episode, in that episode, the 10th said that he is going down there as
an act of faith, and maybe the reason why he is here is to be proven wrong, or something along those lines.
In the Satan pit episode, there was a creature called the best, he claims to be the devil. The doctor gives the “I’ve seen dime gods” speech,
but the beast keeps laughing, and even though the doctor defeats, or seals, the beast, at the end of the episode he says he doesn’t know what
that was. Skip foreword a few season and enter the 11th, when he mentioned the best he referees to him simply as the devil.
My theory is that something must have happened to make the doctor accept that that thing was the devil, what happened ?
we don’t know, but I guess this thing is left for our imagination.
12 July 2015 at 13:25 #41132@purofilion
I personally the 9th suffering figure.
He just got out of the time war, and knows what it means to suffer and knows true pain.
But you still didn’t answer my question:
are you sure that the quote “I know, Muslims, run and hide right ?” came from the god complex episode ?
Because I watched it twice and didn’t notice it.
Mind you I watched it on DVD, not sure if it makes a difference.
12 July 2015 at 13:17 #41130<h2 class=”user-nicename”>@purofilion</h2>
I don’t remember him saying that.I know he liked the girl doctor who died who died alone, but I don’t remember him saying that quote you mentioned.
12 July 2015 at 13:11 #41129<h2 class=”user-nicename”>@jimthefish What about the beast 10th’s “an act of faith” speech ?</h2>
<h2 class=”user-nicename”>and how the 11th’s simply explains him as being the devil, while Amy</h2>
<h2 class=”user-nicename”>didn’t seem to take it seriously, he was indeed serious.</h2>12 July 2015 at 08:57 #41124The way you use @ and then the member’s name to get his attention.
12 July 2015 at 08:16 #41122Hi again 🙂
Sorry about the comment that is above this one, I don’t know what happened. Can someone delete it ?
I don’t know how to do that.
And how can I call someone ?
12 July 2015 at 08:01 #41121@purofilion
@bluesqueakpip
This is what I been thinking about the issue:
The doctor travels a lot between episodes, and we don’t know how long does has it been since we last saw him
and what happened to him while he was traveling, so we can assume that during his travels he could have encountered indecent that changed his beliefs and believed in God. It may not be mentioned and we might never know if it happened, butit is still a possibility. Here is an example for this: When the Eleventh Doctor first appeared he loved fish and custard, later on we rarely we see him eating them. We can assume that during one of his time travels he found something he loved to eat more then fish and custard and it became his favorite, we don’t know if this did happen, but we can assume it.
The exact same idea can be said about his religious beliefs, we can assume that during his travels he could have encountered Is that possible?11 July 2015 at 11:57 #41111Hello everyone
My name is XtremeZ, nice to meet you 🙂
I am a big fan of Doctor who, so much that I have all of the episodes on DVD 🙂
I have two questions I would like to ask:
1- Are the Doctor Who comics and prose canon ?
Now, first of all let me explain what I mean by canon.
I mean are the events that happen in the comics and prose are in the same universe of the show ?
And are the events that happen there happen to the same doctor that is on the show, or is he
another version of him ?
2- Do we know anything about the doctor’s religious beliefs ?
And if we do, what are they ?
NOTE: Please accept my apologies if this is not the right place to ask my question. If this is not the place, then
please direct me to a place where I can ask my questions.
-
AuthorPosts
