• Arbutus replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    @Perry

    First of all, I don’t think it’s possible to compare AG and BG Who, because that implies two distinct entities, when in reality there are more than that. You can’t even really compare different Doctors’ eras, because the style of the show changed considerably from one end of the Tom Baker era to the other, and from McCoy’s first season to…[Read more]

  • Spider replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    @Perry

    Fair enough, in that case, my opinions is as i said in #34962  the boy done good.

    And again for the record, my prediction is Jamie Mathieson will be the next show runner.

    ((;;/)/)

  • Spider replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    @Perry

    Nope. Still not getting it. What is the question?

    ((|;;/)/)

  • RobertDaller replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    @Perry
    First off I have watched some of the classic series, (And intend to watch all the way through) But from everything i’ve seen, and watched, the modern series is still superior in my opinion. (I’ve seen all episode’s of it)

    In the Russel T. Davies era, I feel like we got perhaps some of if not the greatest stories in Doctor Who.
    Specifically…[Read more]

  • Spider replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    @Perry okaaay, you haven’t watched 6-8. so why exactly are you asking the question!?

    Are you wondering if it’s ‘worthwhile’ watching the next 3 seasons? well…yes of course it is.

    If you aren’t looking for a bit of ‘nit-picking’ of episodes, not sure you’ve come to the right place 😉

    So, in essence: What’s your point caller?

    ((;;/)/)

     

  • Spider replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    @Perry  well firstly … what do YOU think?

    Secondly. If he stopped now: He has left behind the crafting of 2 Doctors, multiple companions, multiple Christmas episodes, the 50th Anniversary episode and many of the best loved/rated episodes in the rebooted series (blink, girl in the fireplace, etc etc etc).

    SO, overall IMO: The boy done…[Read more]