@Schamster @lisa

Your posts got me thinking. I was wondering if, perhaps, CapDoc had known where Gallifrey was hidden at the end of tDotD, he may have even been the one who hid it. Missy was showing off by saying the co-ordinates to show that she knew where it had been. (The Master had been sent back into the timelock with Rassilion in tEoT.) Th…[Read more]

@Schamster, genius! Just not arrived yet! 😀

@Schamster – So when all the Time lords came to the save Galifrey party maybe it didn’t even matter
if Capdoc remembers cause when Smithdoc spoke to TomDoc in the gallery TomDoc told him he would need
to search for Galifrey and at that specific moment he wasn’t crossing any time line. Therefore, Capdoc
should be able to recall SmithDocs memories…[Read more]

@Schamster

I’m just not sure it’s on Gallifrey.

Is that because of the sky colour? But we get green skies, red skies, orange skies on Earth, as well as our standard blue. Gallifrey had a war on – those sky trenches may well have affected the colour.

@Schamster  — I do like that idea — a revisit from Capdoc’s p.o.v.!  I’m curious about memory for the Doctor (any of him, really).  As a person who thinks reincarnation is the most likely form of an “afterlife” for humans, it makes sense to me that we generally *don’t* start a our current life with access to our last lifetime, let alone the 50…[Read more]

@Schamster – Doesn’t Capdoc remember himself being there thru memories he inherited from
the SmithDoc? Because SmithDoc knows that he showed up SmithDoc must recall that specific
moment and how they all came together and why. While I agree there would have to be
numerous holes in his memories of the event I have to think still that he has to…[Read more]

@Schamster The barn is referenced again in Listen – Clara says something to the young Doctor along the lines of 1 day you’ll come back to this barn and you’ll be very scared, accompanied by an image of Hurt Doctor approaching the barn. We are clearly meant to see them as the same.

Apologies for my phrasing in the earlier post – I said timelocked…[Read more]

Interesting discussion.  I agreee that Capaldi’s Doctor is still working on the calculations to complete his part of the hding of Gallifrey. Remember that in the Day of the Doctor that they didn’t KNOW that the Doctors’ intervention would result in a better solution than timelocking the planet, but they HOPED that it would.

But the events in Liste…[Read more]

@Schamster — Thanks!  I somehow forgot that bit of the dialog between Matt Smith and Tom Bakker in front of the painting.  Did Baker say *why* Gallifrey has to be found — I mean, apart from the discomfort of being frozen in time until that happens (although if the people of Gallifrey are *really* frozen in time, doesn’t that mean that their m…[Read more]

@Schamster — I recall that was an alternate universe that Romama chose to stay behind in?
So wouldn’t the Curator Doctor Tom have known this? He might have mentioned it at the time of
his meeting SmithDoc in the museum or a least a clue! I guess he felt he had a good reason
not to but this is all very interesting