Real life has been getting in the way over the past couple of days, leaving me barely enough time to keep up with this thread, let alone post my own reactions, and most of the points arising from my thoughts on first viewing have already been raised and discussed at length.

My feelings about this episode are mixed.  I found the dramatic tension,…[Read more]

@scotsman418

My argument is valid and I have seen many people not only on this forum but others like it too.

Two things

1. I can’t see anyone saying your view is invalid. Protest too much yada yada.

2. Appeal to popularity is just about the most specious logical fallacy of the lot (a point rather ably demonstrated within this episode).

@scotsman418 Sorry to hear you didn’t enjoy the episode. That’s totally up to you of course but….

“Looking forward to the assistant being left with the Daleks?” What are you talking about? Are you referring to Asylum? Because that is an old episode with a different character.

Although I’m not totally with any of the science in this episode…[Read more]