[Macca @replies]

Hello everyone how are we all?

Just been thinking about how important Dr.Who was to me and my family on Christmas Day and how kids these days don’t get that anymore due to chibsy, who else thinks that they should bring Doctor Who back onto our screens at 7 or 8 o’clock on Christmas day because I do. Also, I was watching an interview featuring David and Matt a while back on Youtube and they were discussing a really cool idea of each Christmas a different Doctor gets the story so one year we could have Capaldi, the next year Eccleston and the year after Tennant/Smith maybe even McGann, this idea sounds so cool to me and especially if the BBC didn’t spoil which Doctor it was but I guess they would have to for the marketing of the show.

[Macca @replies]

hi @winston that’s cool how your from Canada I’m from Liverpool in England, I’ve been watching Dr.Who for a very long time now since I was very little being probably 4 or 5 years old I started on series 3. I would have to say David Tennant is my favourite Doctor as he was the first one I watched and got the most enjoyable episodes out of overall and his companions too were amazing. I did really enjoy Matt Smith’s doctor too it was hard to like him at first having just lost my “hero” as I looked up to number 10 as a kid but yeah 11s run was really good it just went a bit down hill after Amy and Rory left in my opinion but some of the episodes were really good tbf it just wasn’t as good but I’d still watch them as I like 11s rein. Capaldi I have mixed opinions on as “the doctor” he’s proper good like but some of his episodes just bore me I think it’s just the writing and stuff cos as I said him as the doctor alone is great it’s just in my opinion only some of his episodes I’d actually watch again the rest I wouldn’t bother watching. Moreover, don’t even get me started on 13 what a real mess of the show they have made in my opinion, they need to sack Chibsy and get literally anyone else in that industry that is a fan of the show as I’m sure anyone of us on here could write the show better, not trying to start any feuds here just putting my opinion out there!

Also, I couldn’t forget about 9, Chris Eccleston better be in the 60th anniversary alongside the 8th doctor Paul McGann if thats how you spell it lol.

[Macca @replies]

Also, I’m from England

[Macca @replies]

Hi @docnerd223 I’m new to the forum too and if you scroll up you can see my first post regarding what I think of the show I’m not too certain but I think I am one of the younger ones on here as I’m 17 going 18 but no disrespect to any “old” fans as age doesn’t matter we use this to talk about our favourite tv show as a way of comparing ideas, theories and thoughts on past and present episodes. I count myself fairly lucky as I grew up with Davide Tennant as my first episode was Dalek’s in Manhattan and watched the show from then and went back when 10 regenerated into 11 to watch Eccleston and resumed to Matt Smith when the 5th series aired on BBC one. But yes welcome to the forum mate!

[Macca @replies]

Hi everyone :), been inactive for few days but hey ho.

Just wanted to come on and say thanks for welcoming me into the forum anyone that I have spoken to has been kind and understanding and I appreciate it as the fandom is still very torn apart at the moment as I have read through some posts and I just don’t agree with some things that have ben said and it’s really interesting that we all have voluminous different opinions regarding our favourite show between us all. I’d go into detail but I’m about to pop out so I just thought I’d say a quick hello.

Just going to finish on a thought, in my opinion turn left, the stolen earth and journeys end together is the Avengers Endgame of Doctor Who or should I say the Empire strikes back of Doctor Who I think those 3 episodes are just perfect I remember watching them as a little kid and being terrified of Davros and even seeing the Doctor someone who doesn’t scare easily at all looking terrified at his computer screen as the face of Davros appeared , and I have to mention just all the companions coming together it really does feel like avengers in a way, moreover when donna tells the doctor that rose is there that scene was perfect and then obviously we know what happens next but yeah quick little input from me anyways have a great day guys talk soon!

[Macca @replies]

@oochillyo Hi, just reading your reply to my post cheers for reading:). My favourite series of new who so far has to be series 4 the specials if that counts as a series which I’m pretty sure it does hbu.  In regards to your opinion (obviously each to their own) I just really didn’t enjoy Capaldi that much I mean I prefer him over Whittaker 100% but for me most of his stories/episodes just didn’t engage me as much now I don’t know if that’s to do with me getting older and becoming an adult but they just weren’t on the same level as Tennant’s or most of Smith’s in my opinion and with Tennant’s and Smiths I can still sit down and enjoy them just as much even after watching them loads of times there still a kick there that makes me enjoy it, as I said it’s my comfort show and when I watch some of Capaldi’s episodes it just doesn’t give me that kick. Don’t get me wrong as the doctor alone Capaldi is great it’s just some of his episodes I was bored stiff watching them and I’m not going to even go there on Whittaker’s as I think it’s pretty obvious what my views are on that front and I’d be here all day. I’m going to list the episodes of Capaldi’s reign that I actually quite like to just give you an idea and don’t worry theres not a lot so I’m not going to be waffling on. So the episodes that I like are: deep breath, into the dalek, Dark Water, Death In Heaven, The Magicians Apprentice, The Witch’s Familiar, Face The Raven, Heaven Sent, Hell Bent, The Husbands Of River Song, Empress Of Mars, World Enough And Time, The Doctor Falls and Twice Upon A time. Now that may seem like alot but when you put into persepctive that he had three seasons it’s not alot and not all of these are even that great these are just PERSONALLY the ones I would watch if I wanted to watch Capaldi as the Doctor, I’m not saying Tennant and Smith or even Eccleston are perfect but again personally there are so many more episodes between those three Doctors that I will happily sit through. Moreover, classic who wise I have watched Tom Baker’s Genisis Of The Daleks and I have watched the Five Doctors but when I have some free time I’ll definitely check some more out:).

@dentarthurdent hi, again as I said like obviously each to your own and if Capaldi’s your favourite thats cool man I just prefer Tennant/Smith. Yes I agree I thought the war doctor was cool af and I really do hope Paul McGann gets a part in the 60th anniversary special as well as Chris Eccleston as it would be so cool. I’d say my favourite companion would have to be a tie between Rose Tyler and Captain Jack or even Mickey Smith. Moreover, I’m so happy we agree on the Chibnall front like honestly plain and simple he’s just a muppet he is literally the Ryan Johnson (The Last Jedi) of Doctor Who and he really needs to get his act together as he’s disregarded so much history within the show and he’s just made it so political it’s actually embarrassing.

 

[Macca @replies]

IDK where to post this or were anyone will see it so here it is,

I don’t know if anyone will actually read this or not but I’m new here as of today so alright to anyone who reads this:), I won’t lie in my opinion ever since Series 7 part 1 finished, personally, Doctor Who went down the drain aside from a few episodes that were well written and actually had a good story such as the name of the doctor, the 50th anniversary special and the time of the doctor and a few more but I don’t want to waffle on. I’m currently 17 years old and I’ve been watching Doctor Who most of my life my first episode was Daleks In Manhattan and I was probably only 4 or 5 years old at the time but I instantly fell in love with the show and continued to watch David through to Matt and went back to watch Chris and I enjoyed these three Doctors in particular thoroughly as it was so enjoyable to watch and the storylines and character development was amazing, it was my childhood I was obsessed with it. The reasoning behind me coming onto this forum is to just voice my opinion regarding the show and being honest for the past few years I’ve sat there and watched my comfort show my childhood show just deteriorate over time especially with series 12’s finale I mean I sat there and watched that and I turned the Tv off and wanted to punch something it angered me so much it was so stupid, I feel sorry for the actors as at the end of the day it’s not their fault but even with saying that the acting is no were near as good as it used to be and I think people will have my back on that one, I think Chibnall needs to get his arse into gear like he tried to do in the new years special and you know what I sat and enjoyed that episode as obviously Captain Jack returned, we got a mention of Rose, our favourite Daleks were back and we got to see some bad guys we hadn’t seen for a long time like the ood, silence and sykorax I don’t know how to spell it lol, so for series 13 I really hope Chibnall continues this as the season 12 finale was a joke I think any fan who actually knows the show would write a better story. Moreover, I’d very much like to hear what other people my age or older think about new who as its just in the gutter at the minute we need another RTD or Moff Chibs isn’t the one.

cheers for reading, wanted to voice my opinion, also I have thought up a theroy that legitimatley brings the 10th Doctor back into Who to reprise his role but before revealing that I’d just like to see if anyone reads this lol.

Macca

[Macca @replies]

I don’t know if anyone will actually read this or not but I’m new here as of today so alright to anyone who reads this:), I won’t lie in my opinion ever since Series 7 part 1 finished, personally, Doctor Who went down the drain aside from a few episodes that were well written and actually had a good story such as the name of the doctor, the 50th anniversary special and the time of the doctor and a few more but I don’t want to waffle on. I’m currently 17 years old and I’ve been watching Doctor Who most of my life my first episode was Daleks In Manhattan and I was probably only 4 or 5 years old at the time but I instantly fell in love with the show and continued to watch David through to Matt and went back to watch Chris and I enjoyed these three Doctors in particular thoroughly as it was so enjoyable to watch and the storylines and character development was amazing, it was my childhood I was obsessed with it. The reasoning behind me coming onto this forum is to just voice my opinion regarding the show and being honest for the past few years I’ve sat there and watched my comfort show my childhood show just deteriorate over time especially with series 12’s finale I mean I sat there and watched that and I turned the Tv off and wanted to punch something it angered me so much it was so stupid, I feel sorry for the actors as at the end of the day it’s not their fault but even with saying that the acting is no were near as good as it used to be and I think people will have my back on that one, I think Chibnall needs to get his arse into gear like he tried to do in the new years special and you know what I sat and enjoyed that episode as obviously Captain Jack returned, we got a mention of Rose, our favourite Daleks were back and we got to see some bad guys we hadn’t seen for a long time like the ood, silence and sykorax I don’t know how to spell it lol, so for series 13 I really hope Chibnall continues this as the season 12 finale was a joke I think any fan who actually knows the show would write a better story. Moreover, I’d very much like to hear what other people my age or older think about new who as its just in the gutter at the minute we need another RTD or Moff Chibs isn’t the one.

cheers for reading, wanted to voice my opinion, also I have thought up a theroy that legitimatley brings the 10th Doctor back into Who to reprise his role but before revealing that I’d just like to see if anyone reads this lol.

Macca

[Author]

Posts