• @thedoctordude

    I am sorry, I don’t follow.

    How does the possibility that the Doctor has been there before account for the two different photos? Edmund only died once and could only have died once.

    It […]

  • @thedoctordude – good point about the chair, that fits well under the “mirroring” thread, and “Clara not acting until she’s been show what to do”. The latter is troubling though – does that mean she was awake all […]

  • thommck replied to the topic S33 (7) 10 – Hide

    @thedoctordude Intrigued by the dark Doctor being the Master. Don’t think it could work because he is locked up with the rest of the Time Lords but intriguing because I’m now wondering if when a time lord […]

  • Bluesqueakpip replied to the topic S33 (7) 10 – Hide

    @thedoctordude

    Yes, she could well know who the Doctor is. If she’s the Doctor’s granddaughter, her mum could have told her. Looking back at the prequel to Bells of St John, two things come across very […]

  • Bluesqueakpip replied to the topic S33 (7) 9 – Cold War

    @HaveYouFedTheFish and @thedoctordude

    I’d agree with ‘Clara can’t physically be the same doctor’. Which is why I’d reckon ‘Chameleon Arch’ – she’d be human then, and we know that humanised Time Lords are so […]

  • @thedoctordude – you are correct the doc has stated he can’t cross his personal time line, notably after adrics death to explain why he can’t just keep popping back to fix things that went awry first/second then […]

  • Bluesqueakpip replied to the topic S33 (7) 9 – Cold War

    What if Clara, human or not, is actually a repository for the doctor’s memories?

    @thedoctordude She could be. Certainly her ambition – or immediate plan – is very much something that might come from residual […]

  • thommck replied to the topic S33 (7) 9 – Cold War

    @thedoctordude but what if someone else sings the song by accident!

  • @thedoctordude The man next to Clara at the grave is her Dad, it’s just slightly poor ‘old man’ make-up. He looks totally different, but he does have those same dodgy eyebrows. So he is definitely ‘somebody’ for […]

  • I think the man standing next to Clara in the grave scene will turn out to be somebody. It would have been as easy to have her standing there by herself yet they chose to put him there

    Hi, @thedoctordude It’s her […]

  • @thedoctordude – by the point asylum occurs, earth has been invaded by daleks (and sent packing) and humans have had many skirmishes the doc name checks exxilon, spiridon and Kembel alone in the ep. It’s probably […]

  • @JanetteB @thedoctordude

    I think Clara’s processing as a dalek was recognised as being incomplete due to her huge strength of will. But as @Bluequeakpip pointed out, although she has the computing skills that […]

  • @thedoctordude, yes, it’s interesting the reference to her mother. I’m tempted, after this last episode to think that the Clara of The Bells of St John is the original- she takes the name Oswin, comes up with ‘Run […]

  • Good points @thedoctordude I assumed that the conversion had failed hence locking her up in the Asylum, though there is certainly something that distinguishes her from the remainder of the crew. I’m not convinced […]