The Tsuranga Conundrum
6 November 2018 at 23:17 #65459Darth Valaryn @troygorsline
I did not make that connection, but I did wonder if Pting was Stitch from the animated movie Lilo and Stitch7 November 2018 at 06:06 #65468ichabod @ichabod
@troyorsline I did wonder if Pting was Stitch
Gargoyle Stitch; or Stitch mutated into something even meaner that Stitch-at-the-start. Definite resemblance.7 November 2018 at 14:48 #65471ardaraith @ardaraith
I’ve got nothing to add, except to say I am thoroughly enjoying this new era. I like the storytelling and focus on relationships, each story offers learning opportunities, and portrays problem solving through team-work. It might lack the excessively complex inner show referencing of the Moffat era, which lent itself to theorizing, but I end each show with a smile on my face and a silly text to my daughter (the other Whovian in the house), so that’s a big plus in my book.7 November 2018 at 21:34 #65472nerys @nerys
I’m really enjoying this new Doctor and her companions. For me, this season harks back to the David Tennant era (whimsy and adventure, but without the Rose angst). The Pting was cute enough to add a bit of humor, but without being Disney-cute … if that makes any sense.
As much as I liked Peter Capaldi’s Doctor, I find Jodie Whittaker’s Doctor more relatable, somehow. And maybe some will consider her too human. Capaldi Doc certainly had an “alien” aspect, which might be more true to form, but occasionally left me feeling cold. I like how this Doctor connects with her companions, and also the other characters. In a world so in need of hope and encouragement, I’m glad that’s how this Doctor rolls!7 November 2018 at 22:30 #65473Azzitay @azzitay
New Doc is OK … but dear Lord , who lets this Chibnall Guy write Stories ??
Please get some decent Sci-Fi Writers … or at least bad Sci – Fi Writers .. anything but these last 2 Episode ****** (insert bad word here).
Get even the baddest SciFi Writer there is , as long as hes a Dr.Who FAN … obviously Mr. Chibnall isnt.
I read FANFICTION better than these last Episodes.7 November 2018 at 22:44 #65474IAmNotAFishIAmAFreeMan @pedant
Dr.Who FAN … obviously Mr. Chibnall isnt.
Oh you were going so well(1) and then you demonstrated who very little you know.
(1) For some values of “well”8 November 2018 at 15:38 #65478nerys @nerys8 November 2018 at 15:45 #65480swordwhale @swordwhale
@troygorsline I also thought of Stitch… much of the P’Ting is a similar sort of indestructible potential weaponized creature… dangerously cute.
I thoroughly enjoy everyone’s critiques of the show (I may learn something as a writer), but have to put in my vote for I LOVE THIS DOC AND THIS SHOW SO FAR!!!
Sorry, not sorry about the stuck caps…
>D9 November 2018 at 05:07 #65507thane16 @thane16
Ladies and Gentleman, welcome to Doctor Who’s first species of modern troll, the Pting: eating through wires and metal, never full, always hungry, never actually eating flesh but surviving on constituent computer parts and 0000s and 1000s. Looks like a toy but be aware of what it does…..
When the Doctor looked at the antimatter machine and said, “I love this conceptually and ….actually,” that’s the way Dad looks at Mum.
Love 🙂 T16.9 November 2018 at 10:13 #65513Chiana @chiana
I watched this episode last night and liked it better than the previous ones. I agree that the Pting was a bit too cute, it reminded me of a piglet and I do love little piggies! Was Chris Chibnall thinking of T’Pau when he came up with the name? I liked the way it was sent off into space quite happy.
I noticed the less ostentatious use of the sonic without the big arm swing, much better! I also quite liked the idea with Yoss of men giving birth to boys and women giving birth to girls, but gave up trying to work out how that actually works biologically.
It was a shame that Ronan was going to be de-commissioned, he would make a good companion at some point in the future, an unemotional character to contrast with the current Doc.
Looks like we could be in for another pc episode next.10 November 2018 at 10:42 #65533Whisht @whisht
Can’t remember now whether I’ve shared my thoughts on this one.
It was kinda fun, again enjoyed Graham and Ryan and really hoping Yaz gets some focus in this week’s and beyond, as I think she’s a really good actress.
Wasn’t sure about the Doctor getting called out for being selfish – felt odd. Sure the Doctor’s been selfish in the past but can’t remember being selfish with other people’s lives at stake, but maybe.
Anyway as for the Pting – what made me smile was that after anyone mentioned its name, I just followed with “… Yang Kipperbang – uh”
;¬)10 November 2018 at 15:17 #65535BJT25 @bjt25
I waited with bated breath for the new series; looking forward to a female Dr.
Looking at the Episodes so far I am a bit depressed.
While some of the story ideas are good the delivery does not work.
Three key problems.
1, Get rid of the tick list of issues to cover; far to many; and this is DR W. Who not a soap!
2, Jodie is a proven good actor so why is she the same in all episodes!
3. The three companions spend to much time just behind the DR.
Female roles in the past episodes have been so much stronger. I think the current Dr should re-generate into Clara!12 November 2018 at 04:37 #65558ichabod @ichabod
@bjt25 2, Jodie is a proven good actor so why is she the same in all episodes!
That’s the writing: so far, it’s been pretty simplistic and shallow (compared with what we’ve become used to with Moffat, that is), but I’m hoping for better as the writers gain more confidence.
Female roles in the past episodes have been so much stronger. I think the current Dr should re-generate into Clara!
Uh, oh. Them’s fightin’ words in some parts of fandom . . . !13 November 2018 at 21:13 #65626Arbutus @arbutus
I’m late to the party, but I loved this. It was set up as a stereotypical corridor-running, danger-on-a-spaceship story, but there was a great emotional payoff. My only real complaint was the creature. I wish it had looked a little less like Stitch! Although they might have been trying to emphasize that it wasn’t truly malevolent (although very, very dangerous).
A few takeaways:
We rejoin a fully-functioning Team TARDIS, as shown by the opening scene. Chibnall clearly understands, from back in the day when we had companion groups, that they work best when they are allowed to split up, and play different rolls as needed. Everyone had a job to do here.
Once again, the guest characters were lovely. I know it could be argued that we don’t gets loads of depth, but I don’t see that there’s room for that in the confines of a single episode that also has to tell a story.
I absolutely loved Ryan’s words of support to the childbearing character (I forget his name). The fact that nobody is truly ready to be a parent, you learn as you go no matter who you are, and that what matters most is being there.
I enjoyed the general’s statement that having this critical illness did not fit with her personal narrative. That scene spoke loads, and all the dynamics of that group of relationships (including android consort) were beautifully done.
There were further hints of a story arc, in the suggestions of dark times in the 65th century. I liked the light touch of the return to a universe in which the Doctor’s reputation might have preceded her.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.