• Arbutus replied to the topic Death in Heaven

    @macphisto96   I’ve seen several people here and elsewhere speak of the missing joy.  I understand that, but that is purposeful.   This is interesting, because I myself have actually felt huge joy in this series. I have laughed out loud, I have smiled, I have sat wide-eyed, and after so many episodes have gone “YES.” Yes, the show has been thoug…[Read more]

  • @RobertDaller

    Danny’s death baffles me a bit, (mostly because of Orson) so hopefully that will get explained in Season 9.

    I suspect it will be somewhat sooner than that.

    Pretty much my only complaint about this entire episode is Osgood dying, yes I understand it was for dramatic storytelling, but they could’ve easily had it be someone we did…

    [Read more]

  • @RobertDaller

    And Moffat for creating the characters of  ‘Vastra and Jenny’ (Again sorry, but I hate them, you’re free to have your opinion though.)

    It is worth noting that Vastra and Jenny came back very much through popular demand (as did Strax). Like River Song they were conceived as one-offs.

    Of course, popular demand isn’t necessarily a good…[Read more]

  • FlirtingDinosaur replied to the topic Dark Water

    I’ve so far seen the episode only once an will defenitly have a rewatch before saturday (get here already!!). also i haven’t had the time to read through all of your posts, working on it, but I got impatient ;D

     

    I really enyoed it. it had me on the edge of my sofa, simply because I can’t wait to fu**ing know everything ALREADY! which I probably…[Read more]

  • Craig replied to the topic Dark Water

    @ScaryB Glad you like the new look. I don’t think it’ll last long though. Enjoy it while you can!

    Re @RobertDaller ‘s post, it’s just a discussion of the episode, no spoilers. Robert, once the episode has aired it can be freely discussed and mentioning what happens in it does not count as a spoiler. Spoilers are only mentions of what has not yet…[Read more]

  • ScaryB replied to the topic Dark Water

    @PhileasF Thanks for the screengrabs. Very interesting!

    @Margaret-Blaine Don’t let the odd post-scramble put you off posting. It happens occasionally, don’t know why. (Welcome to the dark (water) side 😉 )

    @jack Re Dr Sarkosa – he would appear to be dead and cyberised – see the inscription on the skeleton-case in his office

    @RobertDaller The…[Read more]

  • janetteB replied to the topic On The Sofa (5)

    Welcome new members, @technohippy and @RobertDaller

    @Purofilion. Sorry to hear that you have been unwell. Hope you are now on the mend. I was wondering where you were last week and about to send out the search parties…:-)

    Cheers

    Janette

  • Mudlark replied to the topic Flatline

    @lisa and @RobertDaller brought up the idea that Missy was the Woman in the Shop, and after this latest glimpse of Missy and her ‘My Clara …I have chosen well‘, I agree that it looks as if we are being pointed in that direction!  Certainly Missy or someone acting as her agent would fit the part, according to what we know so far.  In fact I …[Read more]