Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 1,501 through 1,550 (of 1,874 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #7744
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @juniperfish – I’m sharing the love for Jenny, with a big dose of love for Vastra and Strax. I really hope that if Moffs “I’m nearer the end than the beginning” is true, he thinks for a while and the BBC decided to make them another tea-time series. So much potential.

    #7742
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    I can’t believe Dan linked to our site in his main text. I can give up my marketing badge!

    I thought it pretty convenient that the kids had discovered all this information on Clara, but it occurs that if the GI inhabits the “interwebz of fear” he may actually be bringing it to their attention for some reason? Hmmm…. some thinking required. And possibly alcohol.

    #7731
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    I actually laughed myself hoarse during that. Just fantastic. All those diabolical fiends that Diana Rigg used to fight as “Emma Peel” – well, she must have taken it all in, because that performance tops them all.

    Loved the Tom Tom joke, and a lovely bit of Yorkshire thrown into the mix. I have a feeling it may outrage some of the more serious minded, but bugger ’em.

    Great reference to the “mouthy Australian” as well.

    #7722
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Welcome back @craig. I guessed you may have been stranded without BBC America, but at least you get the double dose of Who goodness today.

    #7720
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @shazzbot

    I assure you, no one on these boards will hold it against you if the old series is not to your taste. I think when you grew up with it and had your imagination seized, it is much easier to forgive the production values of the time. My niece, who loved Sarah Jane in the new series, watched the showing of “The Hand of Fear” on BBC4 after Elizabeth Sladens death. She watched it all and had a bit of a moment at the end (it’s the story in which Sarah Jane left), but I wouldn’t suggest it ignited the desire to see much more (although she enjoyed Robots of Death and The Five Doctors).

    If you want to dip in more and are interested in the stories there is another option. Virtually all the older series were novelised. They aren’t great literature, but even the worst is a cracking short retelling of the story. They are at their best when the script writer writes his own book and takes the opportunity to expand on the story, or play with the narrative possibilities. They are out of print, but second hand bookshops or stalls can be your friend. In Barnsley market, a stall sells them for 50p each, which is an absolute steal. If you see a Doctor Who story with the Target icon in the corner – it’s a televised story.

    Horror
    I’ve put this one up to give you an idea of the look, but also I think we are seeing a familiar hat in tonight’s episode.

    As I’ve been talking about Peter Davison, this is an extract from “Castrovalva” by Christopher Bidmead.

    There is an official time lord strategy you are taught even as a small child: in circumstances of near defeat you take stock of the forces acting on your behalf, your assets, and then separately assess the forces working against you, your liabilities. This leads directly to the next stage: devising a logical plan that will increase the former and diminish the latter. This dictum had often struck the Doctor as typically Gallifreyan – that is to say arid, abstract and artificial. The only really stimulating thing about defeat, death and disaster is that all the rule books go out of the window, and you are permitted to improvise under the purest inspiration of all – blind panic.

    #7683
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @htpbdet – On the internet, you can meet people who have a low opinion of EVERYTHING and ANYTHING. It’s a remarkable gift to the world. 🙂

    #7681
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Just to add – Peter Davison has a CV well worth a look if you are into weirdness. Both @jimthefish and I will defend “A Very Peculiar Practice” to the Death. As we have touched on Hitchhikers on these blogs, here he is as the “Dish of the Day” in the Restaurant at the End of the Universe.

    #7678
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @Shazzbot

    Yes, I think Starkey is brilliant and having a ball. There is another great link, which I won’t embed as you may have seen it before. Songtaran Carols. Moff has been keen to point out these were all down to Starkey gathering the cast together and writing it.

    I wrote on our memories thread about meeting Tom Baker when I was young at the Blackpool Doctor Who exhibition. Just about the most perfect thing that could happen to an eight year old fan. It’s remarkable how something like that can stay with you.

    #7675
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    I thought this was quite fun for the lead in to the next ep. Dan as Strax doing a Question and Answer session with some kids at the Doctor Who experience.

    I’ll stick it on the Sofa for casual viewing.

    @whohar

    Many thanks for the link. 🙂

    #7658
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @whohar

    Not legitimitely for free I’m afraid. They are produced by Big Finish under licence . The usual form is that a series is released one year, and then a one off broadcast is done on Radio 4xtra just after Christmas (as these were). They are available to Dowload at a slightly reduced cost though.

    After broadcast they go onto i-player for a month, so if you could sort yourself with one of those “ahem” proxy things ex-pats go on about (or if the vaunted overseas subscription to i-player goes online this year) you may be able to enjoy the “Dark Eyes” run next year. This apparently features a damaged “Eight starting to look a bit more like “Nine”.

    http://www.bigfinish.com/ranges/released/eighth-doctor-adventures

    #7655
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @whohar

    Interestingly Doc 7 was the same age as The Rani

    I always entertained the notion that the Doc’s “year group” at the Academy were a troublesome bunch. Argumentative student rebels against a very conservative culture that believed in non-intervention. They all wanted more access with different motivations. The Doctor to explore, The Master to bring “order” (well – his order), Rani to use her scientific knowledge and Drax to turn a fast buck. While it doesn’t really stack up to full scrutiny, it makes a weird kind of sense in the sixties roots of the show, when student radicals were all the rage.

    @htpbdet

    On the age front, I was struggling earlier in the blog. I’m sure there is a throwaway reference to “about three hundred” pretty early on to Vicky during her tenure, but I can’t remember the exact story. I may have to dig out the vids and audio this weekend because it is beginning to bug me! I’ve also said earlier in the blog that the Doctors age is one of those things. I’d say he approximates, sometimes exaggerates for effect, and sometimes decides to be falsely precise because he really can’t be bothered to remember.

    #7640
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Still no word from our mighty keymaster @craig!? I hope he’s OK in that US of A. The last thing we need for international relations is an angry Ming The Merciless because he couldn’t get BBC America. 🙂

    @bobbyfat

    Many thanks – You are right in that there is a lot to pick over on these series. I hope he follows RTD and does a companion to “The Writers Tale” that outlines some of the issues he wanted to touch on. I think it would make a fascinating read.

    Good night everyone.

    #7639
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @bluesqueakpip

    “…she added water to the acid…”. Yep – I’m afraid it could be a law.

    The other one in every school is a joke COSHH assessment on water – “100% of people who have died have injested water…., etc”.

    I did an environmental survey of an old school once, and the office for the head of the Science department had a picture of the structure of C4H4AsH pinned to his door, which made me laugh (cut and paste into google if your chemistry is a bit rusty).

    #7634
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @adlerinthelibrary

    Apologies – My Bad! I really am rubbish at geography. I have no idea if I’m coming or going half the time.

    @juniperfish

    even I didn’t make an episode by episode nail polish colour list

    Oh noes! 🙁 Time for a rewatch? 😀

    @shazzbot

    Aww, now, do I really haveto hold back the hordes of Genghis Khan [i.e. the lemon-puss G readers with an urge to shovel over everything they don’t understand] with shite jokes that only maths nerds and computer programmers laugh at?

    As my old chemistry tutors used to say: “If you’re not part of the solution, you’re part of the precipitate”

    #chemistscanmakecrapjokestoo

    #7626
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @phileasf & @bobbyfat

    Yes, the story motif is strong in the run. I think SMs run, when it is available to view in full retrospect, will be quite telling. It seems so far to be about the power of the story in the same way as Neil Gaiman’s “Sandman” series and @miapatrick s excellent “Neverending Story” analogy.

    If you’ll indulge me, I think Series 5 was a clearly about one particular story – Doctor Who.

    Amelia the child, after an encounter with the Doctor, grows up with an imaginary friend. I think most kids who grew up with the series may know the feeling! She makes her toys and dreams up marvellous adventures with the Doctor, as many of us did. Then one day, she puts away her toys and becomes an adult.

    Then he comes back. He promises to cure her of being an adult (and I think many of us will recognise that feeling as well). The adventures continue until a problem – she finds herself in a universe without the Doctor. She remembers him and he comes back.

    I think it’s a story about the power of the old series that nurtured people like Moffat, Davies, and everyone else who was into it at the time. Even when it went away, people still told the stories, in one form or another. Certain people went into TV and became writers, and when an opportunity to do something came back, they remembered.

    The same thing is happening at the moment. New generations growing up with the Doctor, kids like Lindylee. If the show goes away again, you can guarantee that when this generation grows up they will remember – and remembering with love is what always saves The Doctor and brings him back.

    #7586
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @htpbdet

    Just to tangent on your idea of titles, and being a bit tired of “it’s all a bit Harry Potterish” comments on the G recently:

    BBC Worldwide is proud to announce a new JK Rowling “Young Time Lord” series.

    Doctor Who and the Philosophers Bath

    On being admitted to the Gallifrey Academy of Timelordiness, The Doctor and his new friends The Master and The Rani go on an awayday to Earth in a Type 50 Tardis. What is the secret of the Philosophers Bath owned by Archimedes that kindly Professor Borusa has hinted at? Can his new friends help The Master after he feels “a bit funny” on looking into the Temporal Schism?

    The series continues in the following books:

    Doctor Who and the Chamber of Omega
    Doctor Who and the Prisoner of Shada
    Doctor Who and the Goblet of Rassilon
    Doctor Who and the Order of the White Guardian
    Doctor Who and the Half-Blood Doctor
    Doctor Who and the Deathly Assassin

    I shall be back later!

    #7584
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @adlerinthelibrary

    Excellent – we needed a South American correspondent. Who Worldwide for the 50th year.

    @blenkinsopthebrave

    We shall repel them with wit, and mathematician humour.

    Well said my brave friend. They shall wilt and die on the sunny hillside of our remorseless enthusiasm!

    #7441
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Ha – it appears @omega has entered the building! 🙂

    #7439
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @lula – Just to add to @htpbdet’s information:

    At the time of the Fifth series there was a massive amount of speculation that he was to return because of the symbols you mention. False entries on IMDB even named him in the cast for “The Big Bang”, which were joyfully repeated as fact on the blogs (Never trust a series ender cast list for Who on IMDB – for series 6 it was “Fenric”). When “The Lodger” was released with its mystery of another time travel device, it made the prospect even more enticing – surely Omega would have that knowledge?

    It’s unlikely that Omega fought in the Time War even if he survived the encounter in “Arc of Infinity”. He hated the Time Lords. He certainly has Big Bad credentials though.

    #7414
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    “It’s times like this I wish I still had my scarf” – Time Flight

    As I think you can guess from my post on Tom, he was most definitely my Doctor. So along came his regeneration and we had a vet to fill his shoes. An impossible task!? Well, he managed it for me.

    The era wasn’t without its problems. With three companions to share the TARDIS things seemed a little crowded. For me, Adric was a walking disaster. Tegan just whined throughout her first series. Nyssa was a really interesting character and well performed, but dreadfully underwritten. The script for “Kinda” had been based on the idea of two companions, and so she was given a touch of exhaustion by having her faint in the previous story, and consigned to the TARDIS for the duration of it. Unbelievable.

    The reason for this over-abundance of companions must make Davison laugh his head of these days. At 29, the Producers were worried about what the viewers may make of such a young looking Doctor travelling around with a young lady. When we have Ten and Rose holding hands and Amy throwing herself at a startled Eleven, he must wonder at how times have changed since those “repressed” eighties.

    Adric: So what is a railway station?
    The Doctor: Well, a place where one embarks and disembarks from compartments on wheels drawn along these tracks by a steam engine; rarely on time.
    Nyssa: What a very silly activity.
    The Doctor: D’You think so? As a boy, I always wanted to drive one.
    -Black Orchid

    After two pretty lacklustre episodes Castrovala and Four to Doomsday, the rest of the series picked up. Kinda had a great possession scene and the metaphysical aspects were well realised. Let down by “THE SNAKE”. I thought The Visitation was good, but Black Orchid and Earthshock were both excellent. Time Flight was a bit meh to finish on.

    With Adric dead and Tegan gone I thought we may have had a good series with just Nyssa. As a technologically advanced aristocrat she did have the potential to be a similar character to Romana Mark I – with the Doctor trying to impress her with his own obsession with different societies, but no – Tegan came back.

    His other two series have their hits and misses. I really enjoyed the Black Guardian trilogy of Mawdryn Undead, Terminus and Enlightenment, and The Awakening is great Who. His best was saved till last though. With his new singular entourage in the shape of Peri he went into The Caves of Androzani. Seeing the mechanics of a classic Who double act for the first time in his tenure gives you an idea of how hamstrung having a lot of regulars can be. It’s a cracking story with strong ideas, some real cynicism about corporate power and politics in the B scenes and a great central performance from Davison. Just marvellous.

    “You are a Time Lord, a lord of time. Are there lords in such a small domain?” – Striker, Enlightenment

    Even in the stories I haven’t listed, Davison is always the best thing in the production. Not as brash or immediately commanding as Baker, he could sometimes appear indecisive. He is no wet fish though, as this is the Doctor quite willing to gun Davros down at one point, informing him “I’ve come not as your prisoner, but as your executioner”.

    As he regenerated, I did feel a tinge of sadness. I think that says it all when you look back at whether or not a particular Doctor has been a success for you. I’ll also admire Davison for his links to the show, being both passionate about it, but edging it with a self-mocking sense of humour. As the Brig would say – Splendid Chap.

    #7413
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Oh, and just a note for any newcomers – If you want to give your thoughts on any of the earlier Doctors on this thread, don’t be afraid to post them. The reason we are putting up one Face a month is to stretch out the conversation for the months until the anniversary.

    #7411
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    As it’s May – it really has to be Peter Davison month. So, any thoughts on this chap?
    Fifth Doctor

    An Audience Survey report on his first year can be found here. It was a period of change, with The Doctor consigned to the doldrums of weekday showings rather than the magical realm of Saturday.

    The report shows that:

    “Peter Davison appears to have been accepted as the new Doctor. Although there were a number of unfavourable comparisons with certain predecessors (notably Jon Pertwee) and a couple of suggestions that he should stick to being a vet, the majority of those reporting clearly feel that he has got to grips with the part and now fits in rather well.”

    #7410
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @timeloop – Hi, I’ve edited your post embed the link. With this format, if you are linking to YouTube simply cut and paste the address into your post (ie. “htt……..” etc) and the post will do the rest. No other formatting required.

    #7300
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Just to lower the tone, didn’t “Doctor Spock” release a guide to sex and reproduction for Daleks:

    Forn-i-cate
    Ejac-u-late
    Insem-in-ate
    Nine-month-wait
    Cel-e-brate!

    #7196
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @jimthefish

    I take it “time was rewritten” by the Mods in that thread? I never saw what happened, but two modded posts by you together would indicate some “truncation” of the converation.

    If TS was insulting, he may be in Pre-mod. If he was clearly identified as “Undead” he may be banned, if he had been previously. Since the change in profiles, it can be difficult to tell (all the “Dead” appear live).

    #7195
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @jimthefish & @lula

    It was quite common to wear your wristwatch facing inside when I was younger (I still do). It has a couple of advantages, apart from damage.

    – Much easier to surreptitiously check the time if you’re bored by rubbing your head,etc in meetings/lectures/talking to someone you find dull.

    – You didn’t fall prey to a particular “joke” that did the rounds on a night out. You wait until someone gently inebriated has a pint in their watch hand, and ask them the time. You hope that the muscle memory and relaxed state makes them tip the pint over themselves (I’ve witnessed this on a few occasions). Wearing your watch on the inside means you rotate the other way – throwing your pint onto your tormentor.

    #7194
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @thommck

    While defending this episode from the terrible review it got on the sfx blog

    Ha – I just had a look at your comment on the SFX blog. I loved

    If you want to discuss DW without the hate come and join in all the bonkers theorising at thedoctorwhoforum.com

    Welcome to the marketing team! 😀

    On your previous comment

    I’ve come to realise that whatever errors/mistakes the writers come up with the viewers can always cover it up with a bonkers theory!

    I think it’s always been like that to a certain extent. I wrote a long comment on the G about it (continuity/bonkers theorising, etc) which outlined my own feelings towards it and why I resist the urge to criticise over perceptions of them. I won’t repost, but here is a link if you are interested.


    http://discussion.guardian.co.uk/comment-permalink/18441264

    #7093
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @jimthefish

    And, yes, RE. old truckles. I’m still convinced that TS is the newly regenerated form of Alexander

    Truculent Sheep is indeed Alexander. @juniperfish has an excellent memory and reminded me that dear Xander used to link to his blog. On looking I found a link to when he directed people to his thoughts on JLC in 2012. Pretty conclusive.

    I’ll mention @branfish in this post just as he may see it and realise he could waste his valuable time if he expects sensible debate (I just skimmed and saw he and @GuiltyBystander were attempting something of the type in your DEM thread).

    Apologies all – pretty knackered, so I will leave the bonkers theorising to the night crew. See you soon.

    #7092
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Evening all (and a big hello to newcomers!)

    Sorry I’ve not had time to pop in. Real world interruptions. Just skimmed the thread, but need to digest over a long period I think when I’m a bit more alert.

    I had a rewatch, but the only thing that lept out at me was the dialogue that @phileasf (don’t worry – we like long posts) quoted in his excellent post

    “You call yourself Doctor. Why do you do that? You have a name, I’ve seen it, in one corner of that tiny–’”

    It seemed she wasn’t particularly interested in his name but more why he doesn’t use it and the adoption of “The Doctor”. So perhaps that’s his big secret to be revealed? A story or hint at to why he took “The Name of The Doctor”?

    #6995
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @wolfweed

    Eggs… Flickery lights too…

    Yes – since part 1 we haven’t really been keeping track of the references we were picking up (Christmas, flickering lights, Eggs). I thought the Christmas and Egg references were due to the Christmas and Easter episodes, but it would be interesting to see if there are any other spots.

    A final observation for me tonight:

    The series part 1 was about the Doctor getting confused with other Doctors in a couple of episodes. This part features Professors in that role (absent tonight – none of the characters were all that intelligent). The transition was in Angels in Manhattan. River announces she has become a Professor (from Doctor) on her release. Any thoughts? Is the importance of the title of “The Doctor” being reduced because he is erasing his influence from history?

    #6990
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @besd1

    We really should really produce a “Key” to our abbreviations.

    TBOSJ =”The Bells of St. John”
    AOTD = “Asylum of the Daleks”, etc.

    As soon as you get it, it does remove a lot of effort.

    #6987
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @scaryb

    you’re a “shameless marketing whore”!

    It’s a hat I wear with pride! 😀

    #6984
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Feeling a bit naughty at the moment. Some may have seen some of my rants against nesting on the Guardian featured in articles. The former employee (and now contributer) MartinBellam is the one who featured the infamous one on his blog. He posted a comment and I have replied in a cheeky fashion(Page 2):

    @MartinBelam –

    Martin – as I’m sure you’re aware I’m a long time listener and occasional caller. The book you edited on Who for the Guardian did you proud. Who’s Who? is still available at a remarkably low rate, I notice.

    As you hijacked one of my comments on nesting for your own purposes, can I ask if you would mind returning the favour in some way? I don’t know – like suggesting “The Doctor Who Forum” is a bastion of convivial conversation for the enthusiastic Who Fan unsurpassed in the web. It helps that this is true.

    In the event you ever get to look at it, pop over, join us on the sofa, and have a virtual cuppa while talking Who.

    Resist the “Nesting Consciousness” (Joke (c) BlueSqueakPip, Dec 2012), You know it makes sense.

    It may not survive but for cheek it was worth it. Martin is actually great fun and is an enthusiast himself. I’d laugh my head off if he took me up on the offer.

    Really couldn’t resist it!

    #6965
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @juniperfish

    I think the last “age” update we had was in “Town called Mercy”:

    The Doctor: We evacuate the town. Our ship’s just over the hills. Room for everyone. I’ll pop out, bring it back here. Robert’s your uncle!
    Amy: Really? Simple as that? No crazy schemes, no negotiations?
    The Doctor: I’ve matured. I’m twelve hundred years old now. Plus I don’t want to miss The Archers.

    I think one of Hartnell’s episodes with Vicky established he was “about 300”, but I am struggling to remember which one. So a nine-hundred year difference would be about right (although Pertwee claimed he was thousands of years old – but it really depends upon the Planet he was calculating that by).

    #6954
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    As we had a book called “The History of the Time War”, I thought this might be interesting for our overseas or newer viewers. What Russel T. recorded of the TimeWar. I know @juniperfish enjoyed it in Series 5, and though it worth posting here (long, but scroll over if of no interest).

    Meet The Doctor

    When the Doctor came to Earth – to track down the Nestene Consciousness and its plastic servants, the Autons – he had no intention of finding a human companion. He’d had fellow travellers alongside him before, of course, and most of them human. His favourite species! But that was in the old days, when the universe seemed young and fresh and more inclined to friendly gestures.

    The universe, since then, had changed. At least for the Doctor.

    There had been a War, the Great Time War between the Daleks and the Time Lords. There had been two Time Wars before this – the skirmish between the Halldons and the Eternals, and then the brutal slaughter of the Omnicraven Uprising – and on both occasions, the Doctor’s people had stepped in to settle the matter. The Time Lords had a policy of nin-interference in the affairs of the universe, but on a higher level, in affairs of the Time Vortex, they assumed discreetly the role of protectors. They were the self-appointed keepers of the peace. Until forced to fight.

    Now, the story of the Great (and final) Time War is hard to piece together, because so little survived. Certainly, both had been testing each others strength for many, many years. The Daleks had threatened the Time Lord High Council before, by trying to replace its members with Dalek duplicates. And one of the Dalek Puppet Emperors had openly declared his hostility. Though perhaps the Daleks’ wrath was justifiable – they had been provoked! At one point in their history, the Time Lords had actually sent the Doctor back in time, to prevent the creation of the Daleks. An act of genocide! The Time Lords fired the first shot – though in their defence, they took this course of action because they had foreseen a time when the Daleks would overrun all civilized life and become the dominant life-form in the universe.

    Some tried to find a peaceful solution. While it’s hard to find precise records of these events, it’s said that under the Act of Master Restitution, President Romana opened a peace treaty with the Daleks. Others claim that the Etra Prime Incident began the escalation of events. But whatever the cause – and its almost certain that the full story has yet to be uncovered – the terrible War began. The Time Lords reached back into their own history, to assemble a fleet of Bowships, Black Hole Carriers and N-Forms; the Daleks unleashed the full might of the Deathsmiths of Goth, and launched an awesome fleet into the Vortex, led by the Emperor himself.

    The War raged, but for most species in the universe, life continued as normal. The War was fought in the Vortex, and beyond that, in the Ultimate Void, beyond the eyes and ears of ordinary creatures. The Lesser Species lived in ignorance. If a planet found its history subtle changing – perhaps distorting and rewriting itself under the pressures of the rupturing Vortex – then its people were part of that change, and perceived nothing to be wrong. Only the Higher Species – those further up the evolutionary ladder – saw what was happening. The Forest of Cheem gazed upon the bloodshed, and wept. The Nestene Consciousness lost all of its planets, and found itself mutating under temporal stress. The Greater Animus perished and its Carsenome Walls fell into dust. And it is said that the Eternals themselves watched, and despaired of this reality, and fled their hallowed halls, never to be seen again…

    Years passed, as the mighty armies clashed. And then, silence. No one knows exactly what happened in the final battle. And no one knows how it came to end. All that is known is that one man strode from the wreckage, one man walked free from the ruins of Gallifrey and Skaro. The Time Lord called the Doctor. And his hearts were heavy as he boarded his ship once more, and took to the skies, to escape everything he had just seen; everything he had just done…
    He is alone and thinks, somehow, that he deserves this. And as he wanders on, he decides that no one should stand beside him. He’s got no room, on board his TARDIS. He is a traveler, and needs no other.

    But then he finds himself in the cellar of a London shop at closing time, and he grabs the hand of an Earthling called Rose Tyler, and looks into her eyes, and all those resolutions go out of the window! The journey goes on, with a human at his side, and who knows where it will end…

    And far away, across the universe, on the planet Crafe Tec Heydra, one side of a mountain carries carvings and hieroglyphs, crude representations of an invisible War. The artwork shows two races clashing, one metal, one flesh; a fearsome explosion; and a solitary survivor walking from the wreckage. Solitary? Perhaps not. Under this figure, a phrase has been scratched in the stone, which translates as: you are not alone…

    #6949
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @haveyoufedthefish

    No no no! Ok even just “an” eye of harmony being in the tardis is hugely problematic. Otherwise the premise of a Deadly Assassin is trashed – anyone needing a new regeneration cycle just needs to take a wander down to the heart of any tardis, and the Master, as we know

    If it’s any help, my thinking on this whole “Eye of Harmony” issue is that The TARDIS must have it’s own independent source of energy from Gallifrey. In “The Three Doctors” the Timelords energy is being drained. The only operative in play is The Doctor, with his TARDIS, which still works. After the movie, I just rationalised (ie “Made Up”) that the original Eye powered Gallifrey and gave them their first opportunity for Time Travel. The development of the TARDIS required each to have a similar core.

    The point of the Master attempting to nick the Eye on Gallifrey was to gain his regenerations AND kill the Doctor and Timelords in a massive act of revenge. Plus – using his own TARDIS core to do what he wanted would have left him a bit lost for transport.

    It works for me! 🙂

    #6942
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @bluesqueakpip

    Sorry you didn’t enjoy it, but thanks for confirming my original impression on Clara recognising the name.

    IF it is revealed, I can’t help but think it will be mythology OR a figure associated with learning and Doctors.

    I think that’s why I was drawn to the Hippocratic Oath, some of the wording “throughout time” and “swear falsely” just had echoes.

    It would be interesting if it was something like Hippocrates or Galen (@janneteB will love that being a Babylon 5 Univerise fan).

    #6906
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @juniperfish

    Did anyone else think the salvage team with one supposed android was a call-out to Red Dwarf?

    Twist my nipple-nuts and send me to Alasks (but not the starship) – you could be right! 🙂

    You know, I think MERLIN could work – perhaps that’s why John Hurt is in the 50th anniversary episode?

    #6902
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Was it just me, or did Clara seem to recognise the name? Going back to the speculation on the last thread is his name ……… MERLIN!

    #6900
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @juniperfish

    It was The Cult (I did explain the “Goth” thing didn’t I) although technically in their “Cock-rocker” phase. The track is called “Fire Woman” – links to phoenix?

    #6894
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    I have to say, I actually thought at one point that my theory that Clara was a construct of the Tardis was going to come true. First the explanation of the reconfiguration device (a machine that builds machines) and the scan of the “Zombie” reading “Lancashire, South”. I thought – partly built Clara’s!!!

    Unfortunately, I had to abandon “smug-face”. 😳

    #6891
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @wolfweed

    However Gregor remembers about a bit of kindness because the Dr tells him to.

    It’s funny, because I got the feeling at the end that the Doctor asking her “if she felt safe” was to indicate he had some sort of memories of the events and was testing her. The Gregor scene then seemed to re-inforce that trace memories of those events had survived somehow.

    #6887
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Welcome @wayne1357, make yourself at home – we usually start off slow, but we gain momentum!

    #6885
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @htpbdet

    Glad you made it for the episode. I must admit I had a few distractions and so couldn’t pick up some of the audio references you managed. I did enjoy Ian’s voice in the mix. Lovely to tie in with the notion of an echo console room.

    I really enjoyed that. The B story of the brothers was slight, but it really did build on the Doctor/Clara relationship.

    I think I may need a thorough rewatch in a while when it’s a bit quieter.

    #6865
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @lula

    I think the argument is just that it isn’t how Jon Pertwee pronounced it to be honest.

    If you look at this trailer for “Planet of the Spiders” you and listen out around 40-50 seconds in he says it to Sarah Jane:

    #6861
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @wolfweed

    I was a bit surprised by some of the angst over the Metabilis pronunciation on the G blog as well. I couldn’t help but think of The Eleventh Hour, and The Doctor saying about food:

    “New mouth, new rules..”

    It seems to fit perfectly 🙂

    #6848
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Oh – I just looked at http://www.doctorwhonews.net/ (which is good for DVD releases and other announcements) and noticed in the sidebar that today sees the 27th Birthday of Jenna Louise, and 50th Birthday of Russel T. Happy Birthday to them.

    #6840
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    Just to add to the confusion over “1974”, when it was broadcast live the subtitles said “1972” rather than “1974”. Timey Wimey. 🙂 I’ve not checked i-player to see if it has been corrected.

    #6833
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    @janetteb

    Cheers – I’ll use it tonight.

    @scaryb @juniperfish

    I am the shameless marketing whore for The Doctor Who Forum! 😀

    #6831
    PhaseShift @replies
    Time Lord

    I’ll apologise to @juniperfish and thank @whisht for the conversation on the music thread. I noticed last thing last night that the link you were using was defunct J’Fish, but thought I’d post today.

    A general question:

    would it be useful to have a Q&A post or blog on some of the features on the site? How to use the Personal message fuction, using images and video, etc. We could use it to link to other resources For example, If you’ve wondered what “smilies” are available and the text you use to apply them you can find them here. That kind of thing.

Viewing 50 posts - 1,501 through 1,550 (of 1,874 total)