General Music thread
Home › Forums › Non-Doctor › Music › General Music thread
This topic contains 918 replies, has 44 voices, and was last updated by
Craig 11 years, 10 months ago.
-
AuthorPosts
-
15 December 2013 at 17:30 #22845
For ant buffy and angel fans
16 December 2013 at 19:34 #22921Thanks MartyB – quite a few fans of Van here methinks (though there’s only a few of his I’ve liked).
and I know there’s a lot of Madness love – all the way back to the first page!
now to catch up some
tree-hugging hippymusic as I’m peckish and thinking of fish fingers and custard…😉
17 December 2013 at 12:47 #22969Anonymous @
The storyboards from TDotD (on the BBC website) reminded me of this 80’s classic
18 December 2013 at 10:07 #23034@MartyB You post as much Van the Man as you like, as far as I’m concerned!
(LOL’d at @whisht‘s Mr Scruff)
@phaseshift‘s recent On the Sofa post reminded me how dire Xmas shopping music is. The alternative Xmas soundtrack starts here. This is for Keef (aka Mr Riff), who’s 70 today 🙂
18 December 2013 at 10:21 #23037Anonymous @
18 December 2013 at 22:20 #23079ah @scaryb – wonderful – xmas music!
Now that is one helluva track (never come across that one before!).
At chez Whisht (and assorted workplaces who are stoopid enough to allow me to put music on) this album always gets a spin. I genuinely love it.
@phaseshift – its time for xmas, but its also time for jazzzzzzz
19 December 2013 at 01:30 #23089Anonymous @
@whisht @scaryb thank you for the great jazz above. I recall in 1985, during a music course, some of us had to get up and, frighteningly on the spot, play some Baroque music and segue into jazz. I chose one of Bach’s preludes -Number 6, and then did some simple jazz renditions. At the end I included a few bars, in a minor key (with some 6ths and 7ths), of the Doctor Who theme. They were utterly puzzled. This crowd of 17 year olds had never heard it. Only the tutor! Later, I found a group who were Doctor Who and jazz mad fans. Thank goodness. Without jazz, it just wouldn’t be Christmas.
Kindest,
purofilion
19 December 2013 at 01:44 #23090@MartyB Wholeheartedly agree with you re The Last Waltz. Sets the standard. Apparently it came about almost accidentally when Robbie Robertson suggested that as it was the Band’s last gig that maybe they should get it filmed, just for the record. Oh and his friend Martin (Scorcese) had a camera and might be able to help out! The next thing they know they’ve got a multi camera team and full crew running all over the place.
@whisht – Anything with Charlie Brown works for me! (Seriously, I really enjoyed that)
@Purofilion – I’m generally more of a rock n roll girl myself, but like to stray into music’s various other highways and byways as well. Which is a sneaky way of easing in a link to more from the Belfast Cowboy 😉
19 December 2013 at 02:06 #23092@MartyB @scaryb @purofilion
Yes! to The Last Waltz, and indeed, anything to do with The Band. And to anything by Van Morrison. And to jazz at Christmas, and almost any kind of Christmas music, for that matter. Our Christmas playlist skips with abandon between traditional choirs, classic pop and rock, jazz, and all kinds of very esoteric early music repertoire. Here is my attempt to embed a video, let’s see if it works. Is anyone familiar with Straight No Chaser?
19 December 2013 at 02:08 #23093That A-ha song has had a bit of a resurgence as it was referenced earlier this year in a pop song by Christina Aguilera. I only know this because the teenager in the house was listening to it in the summer, and his dad and I both exclaimed triumphantly, “We know that song!” The original is now on my son’s playlist, and I think he actually likes it better than the song in which it reappeared. 🙂
19 December 2013 at 03:10 #23094@everyone
loving the music!
@whisht, two delighted thumbs up for Vince and Charlie Brown.
@scaryb, @whisht, @MartyB, seconding, thirding, and fourthing Van Morrison. and The Band. and a belated happy birthday to Keith.
and yes, @arbutus, I have heard of Straight, No Chaser. I’ve even heard them, though not in concert.
Since your linked song included a tip of the hat to Hanukkah, I thought I’d add to the ecumenicalism of the season by sharing this solstice song I learned a back-to-nature-potentially-tree-hugging-hippy friend — if I can get it to embed correctly!
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=light+is+returning+youtube
TardisBlue
19 December 2013 at 03:13 #23095https://duckduckgo.com/?q=light+is+returning+youtube
trying again … old dog new tricks and all that
19 December 2013 at 03:17 #23096😛
insert/edit link aka alt shift a doesn’t seem to be working for me. :'( I’m gonna ask Santa for a teenager with computer skills for Christmas!
TB
19 December 2013 at 06:42 #23100Anonymous @
You’ve linked to a search for a song on YT, not the song itself.
I’m not familiar with Light is Returning so I just grabbed the first one I saw using your search. Is this what you wanted to share with us?
19 December 2013 at 06:47 #23102Anonymous @
@jimthefish, @craig, @phaseshift, @fatmaninabox
There’s a strange double line (two instead of the usual one post separator line) between posts 23094 and 23095 here on the Music thread. The formatting of submitted posts goes strange after that. Is there some extraneous code that you can see in page edit mode that slipped in at that point?
19 December 2013 at 06:57 #23103Anonymous @
@MartyB – Thanks for that. All fixed now 🙂
19 December 2013 at 07:08 #23105Anonymous @
Damn @fatmaninabox, you’re quick.
Decided on that lining colour for your new box yet? 😉 You need a shade which will set off your features and not overwhelm them. Your current black is tasteful but a tad funereal.
19 December 2013 at 07:42 #23107Anonymous @
@MartyB believe it or not, I was just about to fix it when your comment popped up!
Hmm, box lining. I was thinking maybe purple. Or red. Reddish Purple? Purplish red? Something ‘regal’ anyway 🙂
19 December 2013 at 08:25 #23113Anonymous @
@arbutus — here’s Australia for you. I was listening to this on my front perch -your FANTASTIC vid clip! one neighbour and their flat mates popped their heads out and now 16 people are watching in flip flops and with beers. Brilliant. Tar, as they say
19 December 2013 at 08:38 #23114Anonymous @
@arbutus -if that’s your first go at embedding ? then fantastic. I expect, as do the neighbours, several ‘mazing more choral/chorales attributes daily. Honestly, by the time TOTO was ‘referenced’, some of them, being ’80s guys, were dancing on the street: 12 flip flops flapping, 11 beers ‘aswilling’, 10 daggy boardies; 9 sleeveless T-shirts; 8 sun burned faces; 7 stringy sun-hats. Yep, you get the picture. 30 degrees and it’s nearly 7 pm. Kindest, Purofilion
19 December 2013 at 09:54 #23116Anonymous @
@MartyB and @tardisblue that was lovely -if it was the one or not. I liked the modulation and circle of 5ths throughout this- ‘the planet is turning; light is returning through the darkest hour’ etc. is appropriate when considering both Christmas and the Doctor. And the nice major finish in the penultimate bar. “Niiice, dude” as the child would say.
19 December 2013 at 10:30 #23118@MartyB,
thanks! That was the one I wanted to share.
@purofilion,
So glad you liked it. Isn’t the call and response with the gospel choir toward the end so wonderfully full of energy? Such a great winter solstice song – at least here in the northern hemisphere.
I hadn’t even considered its applicability to next week’s Doctor Who Christmas special. You’re one smart cookie!
TardisBlue
19 December 2013 at 11:19 #23121Anonymous @
@tardisblue indeed, C&R is a great gospel-style tradition for this time of year. As for smart cookie -you’re too kind ‘coz I aint’ ! I like listening to moosic appropriate in cooler climes. It makes me think of snow and mini Christmas lights, of warmed wine and icy breaths. Here, well, we just sweat. Not very ‘Christmasy’. Still, one must not complain. We have electricity and so far, neither floods nor fires this season, yet.
19 December 2013 at 18:49 #23131@tardisblue Wonderful! I have very fond memories of “Light is Returning”, as it was sung every year in my son’s primary school. They sang it in a more aboriginal style, in keeping with our Pacific northwest part of the world, but I love the gospel feel of this version.
19 December 2013 at 18:50 #23132@purofilion
What a wonderful image I now have of you and your neighbours! Very communal. I love your “Australian 12 Days of Christmas”; what is in the pear tree? I have always loved the moment in that version when they suddenly morph into “Africa”; for anyone of a certain generation, that song produces an instant jolt of recognition.
For the benefit of any mods present, I have to say that I just followed the instructions in the “help” section of the forum on embedding videos. It worked like a charm!
19 December 2013 at 18:52 #23133@purofilion Here, well, we just sweat. Not very ‘Christmasy’.
My mother lives in Calgary, caught between the prairie and the Rocky Mountains, and every year she complains about having to miss some event due to unexpected snow. (In Calgary, one can reliably expect “unexpected snow” at any point over about 9 1/2 months of the year.) Perhaps I shall suggest that she move to Australia. 🙂
19 December 2013 at 20:38 #23138Wow – excellent @arbutus – not heard of them but really enjoyed it! And @tardisblue that’s a great track!
oooohhhh… this is spurring on so many ping-pongs…!
@purofilion – really jealous of your knowledge of how music works (have tried reading a simple kid’s ABC on music, watched wonderful programmes such as Howard Goodhall’s history of music, read The Rest is Noise etc etc but I still obviously don’t care enough to ‘get’ it. Instead I have to use my ear, which (though not ‘bad’ – I learned to play simple stuff on tin whistle and harmonica) is limiting and downright lazy. Every time I hear you and people like you I’m spurred on to actually getting off my arse (or ear) and learning (or at least practising).
So, there was a wonderful bit of gospel above and (although i was gonna go a bit awkward with blues river c&r stuff but that’s all me me me not the music) I tried Sweet Honey in the Rock and a few others but… I had to fall back on the best – however… all the carols and seasonal stuff I’ve yootoobed tonight is … well I don’t hear the ‘heart’.
So, for anyone who likes Mahalia – and for anyone who is (foolishly) wishing it weren’t so darn hot… in London its cold and its raining
Not exactly a carol but I hope it warms you up!
20 December 2013 at 10:15 #23142Anonymous @
For those who thought they’d missed out on all the Christmas songs (lucky sods 😉 ) by doing their shopping online (yes, @MartyB I mean you 🙂 ), here’s some Cliff… 😈
20 December 2013 at 10:25 #23143Anonymous @
Some Christmassy ditties from Doctor Who
20 December 2013 at 10:55 #23147Anonymous @
Aaaaah! @fatmaninabox
My ears are bleeding

(I meant, about The Ageless Christian obviously)
How about the Worst Christmas Song Ever?
20 December 2013 at 11:28 #23150Anonymous @
@MartyB – now my ears are bleeding. It seemed promising till the rapping started 🙂
I can only follow that with the best Christmas song ever.
20 December 2013 at 18:34 #23160Anonymous @
@whisht @fatmaninabox my music buddies and @ everyone else — head-banging Christmas cheer, via The Trans-Siberian Orchestra
See, @scaryb? I do Christmas as well. 😀
20 December 2013 at 18:37 #23161Anonymous @
And another Christmas favourite — there aren’t too many versions available online (none live that I could find) but at least this one has the lyrics
And if you want the version with gaudy (and severely entertaining) American light display instead
20 December 2013 at 18:44 #23163@whisht Isn’t Mahalia astonishing? She was always a part of my Christmas soundscape as a child, because my stepfather loved her. I find it quite wonderful how some people are able to channel their personal faith into something that is just so uplifting. Mahalia’s voice was incredible, but it was the spirit shining through that makes her music so memorable.
Re: The Rest is Noise, are you talking about Alex Ross’s blog or his book? The book is wonderful, it really inspired my husband and me to get out of our musical comfort zone and start listening more adventurously.
20 December 2013 at 18:51 #23165
I offer up to everyone my favourite Bizarro comic strip, which has been stuck up on our fridge for years because I never get tired of it. I think that anyone who has ever sung in a choir will appreciate it on all its levels!
20 December 2013 at 18:59 #23167@MartyB Worst Christmas Song Ever – No kidding! The weirdness in that video is that he seems at times to have a point that he is trying to make, but it doesn’t work because the whole thing is so bizarre. If it was just meant to be ludicrous, he would have been better off to leave out the social commentary bits.
The Trans-Siberian Orchestra is good fun. We also like the Mannheim Steamroller at Christmas, so in return, I give you:
20 December 2013 at 19:57 #23177Anonymous @
Some Muppet Christmas mayhem 🙂
20 December 2013 at 20:57 #23181@fatmaninabox – Great Muppet vid! Thanks!
21 December 2013 at 00:16 #23183Anonymous @
@fatmaninabox I can’t believe I woke up to ‘Stop the Cavalry’. Fantastic! Thank you: The Box. I play it every Christmas and jump around the house. This forum is surely my home away from home! I also play a song, that surprisingly (I think) is by Madonna. I believe it’s a Christmas song, too. Can’t find it anywhere Thank you @MartyB for the choral tidbits s well…Kindest, purofilion
22 December 2013 at 11:17 #23226he he – there’s a ton of good stuff here that I’ll listen to later while having a glass of white port (my god what a discovery that was!) and wrapping the final presents.
Although this could have been embarrassing, Kim Wilde has said she really enjoyed this and (yes) was completely and utterly plastered!!
It left me with a big smile anyway!
23 December 2013 at 20:09 #23299Anonymous @
Personally, I always thought the line ‘Doctor In The TARDIS’ was is reference to this, erm ‘dancefloor classic’ 😉
23 December 2013 at 21:11 #23301Anonymous @
The incomparable Tim Minchin ‘I Really Like Christmas‘
I guess I have all of the usual objections
to consumerism, to the commercialisation of an ancient religionTo the Westernisation of a dead Palestinian
press-ganged into selling Playstations … and beer.And the other side of the coin, it’s the Charlie Brown Christmas.
The full Vince Guaraldi Trio Album
Jazz Christmas to you and all of yours.
Joyeux NoëlThe skirting boards were bloody stars. 🙂
23 December 2013 at 22:14 #23304@arbutus – loving that cartoon 🙂
@MartyB – I don’t know where to begin with the worst xmas song ever so I won’t – its unforgiveable!! However – Charlie Brown redeem’s most things!
🙂
Similarly – nothing can forgive @fatmaninabox ‘s The Timelords horror – except of course a judicious muppet song!!
(as well as a rather fetching seasonal avatar update!).I’ll leave you to decide if this is me being ironic, cheeky, Who-ish or simply because its a great choon.
(hm, methinks that could’ve been another poll …)
24 December 2013 at 18:57 #23338Thanks everyone for all the music contributions for Christmas.
In keeping with the happy-sad occasion that is tomorrow’s Christmas Dr Who, and Matt’s bowing out, I would like to leave you with possibly the saddest Christmas song ever. The inimitable Alex Harvey from 1964 (and as you maybe haven’t heard him before). Tissues at the ready =) Happy Christmas everyone, see you on the other side (or maybe sooner!)
25 December 2013 at 04:32 #23347Anonymous @
A Christmas favourite of mine (and the only time I’ll willingly go to the theatre) is The Nutcracker. Here’s the Fantasia version (still images only I’m afraid).
@scaryb – Blimey, I’ve never heard Alex Harvey like that 😯 I’m used to hearing TSAHB like this…
25 December 2013 at 06:01 #23348My favourite Christmas song is Lilly the Pink.
25 December 2013 at 06:24 #23351Anonymous @
I’ll drink to that 😀
“Christopher Eccles
tonhad terrible freckles
and they covered all his face
And so they gave him Medicinal Compound
Now he travels through Time and Space”25 December 2013 at 09:50 #23353Merry Christmas!
27 December 2013 at 15:33 #23481So, as we say goodbye to our Madman in a Box, I found myself listening to the following: Murray Gold’s own reflection on mortality, in his tribute to Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart.
31 December 2013 at 13:00 #23699Happy birthday to us – IT’S TOO LATE TO STOP NOW!
(tenuous link to Van Morrison 😉 )
-
AuthorPosts
The topic ‘General Music thread’ is closed to new replies.


