If an unethical act is required to save all life does that make it ethical?

@JanetteB and @ScaryB – ooh, entire books have been written about that one. Generally, no. See, that was easy. 🙂

The phrase ‘the […]

@chickenelly @JanetteB @ScaryB –

I did wonder if we’ve been given a bit of a misdirect in terms of why the Silence wanted to kill the Doctor, and who Madam Kovarian’s ‘endless bitter war’ was actually between.  […]

@brotherjohn.

Agreed – I think the Trenzalore prophecy has happened. Silence did fall – all the stars in the Universe went out. Pretty quiet after that I think.

@Timeloop @ScaryB

Of course, all and any […]

@ScaryB Is there no possiblity that Clara could have interfered in the first meeting with 2nd Doc? If we saw that form a viewpoint were Tranzalore already happened it could work … ._.

@ScaryB

Maybe the van Gogh painting isn’t two Tardii colliding, maybe it’s one Tardis splitting into two.

@ScaryB

I tend to agree with @JimTheFish that separate threads is a route Iwouldn’t want to go down. It has occured to me though that a single thread for questions (even if on old Who) that crop up in episode […]

@ScaryB @JimTheFish @Whisht

I am taking notes. I’m just not responding because the events at Trenzalore suddenly seem much more easy to solve than where we go from here 😀

I’ll have a long bath and a think […]

@ScaryB Surely he can do “I don’t want to go” just one more time! Just for us? 😀

And if there are 2 Doctors can there be 2 TRADISs, one to die at Trenzalore, the other to continue on her voyage with the newly […]

@ScaryB

Speaking about the tricksy nature of prophecies, the one in Harry Potter, which is supposed to foretell the person who will bump of Voldemort, I’m still convinced actually refers to Snape.

I might be […]

@ScaryB

“In the Dr’s defence River took the decision out of his hands (well his mouth), the Dr wouldn’t have let his friends die, having gone all the way to Trenzalore (the one place he should never ever go) […]

@ScaryB I’ve replied to Mini-HTPBDET(S), thanking him for the update. I ended it by saying “Please send him all our best wishes, tell him we are all glad he is writing again, and that we are all waiting for his […]

@ScaryB  – first off thanks for the hello and tips and advise 🙂  I finally feel like I landed in the deep end of the swiming pool and I am loving it!! lol

Also I have to say I am leaning toward and hoping that […]

I think the Silence are going to be very confused…!

@ScaryB – not half as confused as I was after writing that post! 😀

@ScaryB

So are we back to HurtDr being possibly preHartnell (has that one still got legs?), between 8/9, or between 10/11 or he’s after 11?

You forgot between 2 and 3. I see that as the only other good […]

@ScaryB “And finally (possibly!)

@Juniperfish

Some unknown force was controlling the TARDIS in The Big Bang – the one with the hissing voice. I think some very clever person either here or on the G-blog […]

@ScaryB ” @Juniperfish Well @DanMartinUK said that Moff told him that he and Matt read all the comments (they must be mad, masochistic or incredibly thick skinned).  I’m sure that’s why it all suddenly seems to be […]

@ScaryB – I’m sure we’re all a bit guardian-tree-huggy to some extent, so shouldn’t we maybe recycle our theories first..?

I mean, I had the Silence guarding the Doctor’s secret…. rather than the Whispermen […]

@ScaryB 😀 Courtesy of @Whisht.

@BadWulf Sorry, what’s series 6C about? I’m still going for the first theory but open to other past tense ones!

@chickenelly Yes, Ten got shot by a Dalek in Journey’s End and […]

@ScaryB Lol at beige formica tops ! That really would be evil 🙂

Thanks @ScaryB and @Juniperfish

I didn’t get too spoilered. I saw pictures of Clara with other Doctors, but seeing as that all happened at the start of the episode it wasn’t too bad. And like others I saw the […]