Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
16 November 2014 at 18:47 #35684
@badwulf and @purofilion Yes it’s Rusty the ‘good’ Dalek. He’s still out there – wouldn’t that be an
really interesting conflict between a good Dalek and Dr. Skarosa/Cyberman ? I for 1 would like to
see how that would shake out — I need to find more clues cause love investigating the mystery – if
anyone comes up with anything about this chime in !!!!16 November 2014 at 04:58 #35659@purfilion -lol but wait there’s more – they also had a flashback to dalek caan in this episode!
why that particular flashback? It’s feeling to me like we are heading for lots more great and
grand deceptions16 November 2014 at 04:31 #35657@purofilion sorry cause that last post was lots of thoughts not well connected
So basically Dalek Caan got Davros out of the time lock
Davros might have then helped Nissy out of time lock knowing how to from Dalek Caan
then Davros may be planning a great revenge deception like Dalek Caan did
and lastly Dalek Caan had a prison ship and Missy mentioned a prison camp and the
netersphere felt somewhat like a prison camp to me
that’s pretty much what I got just now16 November 2014 at 02:15 #35653@purofilion hi ! So wouldn’t hiding inside a cyberman be a perfect place for Davros!
Ok so I looked up some stuff -Dalek Caan escaped the time war thru a temporal shift and
rescued Davros. Caan also stole a prison ship made by time lords and escaped with it inside
the void by using [that was the doomsday episode] some special ship that had tardis tech
– Missy mentioned a Dalek camp in the episode? Maybe Darvos plans to
deceive everyone the way Dalek Caan deceived him ? Also – the master was resurrected
by Rasilon but ‘ran away’ to the end of the universe but then found out what Rasilon did
and fell into the time lock with him – So maybe Davros thinks he could use te Master’s
hatred and anger over what happened to him and he rescues the Master out of the time lock
with the knowledge he had from Dalek Caan how to do that
I like your notion about going along for the ride but not pulling any strings of the puppet/master –yet16 November 2014 at 00:26 #35645Or maybe Davros didn’t get trapped in that time lock? In which case it would still be interesting
The Master/Missy is one of Davros great rivals but they both hold similar grudges and
are equally ruthless. [Actually he might be really upset with the daleks after that 10th Doctor
crucible incident and maybe he has it in for them especially considering the betrayal by Dalek cahn]
I think I saw someplace that it was implied that the Supreme Dalek got Davros out of the time lock
so that would mean that Davros knew how to get out and could of gotten the Master out too?15 November 2014 at 23:58 #35639I was thinking about Dr. Skarosa maybe aka Davros?? so why? well wasn’t he also trapped in the time bubble?
Could Missy and Davros have joined forces together in a pact to escape the time lock – Missy gets from
Darvos the DNA tech to make an army to gift to the Doctor and Davros get a new mobile body plus the ability
to sabotage the cybers and maybe rebuild a new Skaro on Earth to fight against the galifreyans ?
{this is what came into my head while I was having a bike ride with my kid- obsessed much?? lol]15 November 2014 at 21:01 #35622@danmartin — I have seen your blog in the Guardian and have also previously made similar remarks
as you have regarding the comments. So I was just wondering about what you were thinking about
the new format that they were using? To me it is very much more like ‘tabloid’. So to me I
was wondering if that might in some way unintentionally contribute to the increase in ‘tabloid-ish’
commentaries? I don’t think this new format is a real improvement. It makes the content seems less
serious [if that’s the right word]? In a world filled with so much turbulence it seems wrong to
me to be taking current events less serious. But that’s just IMHO
Hope to hear from you about the DVD event!15 November 2014 at 20:11 #35619@mudlark Thanks for properly fixing my memory of that !! Sometimes the little grey cells
don’t serve me as I would hope that they would. Your explanation was totally an “Oh Yeah”
moment. Although I still have a question about the graveyard cybers getting a ticket back
into the nethersphere – and for that matter who was the cyber that was inside Dr Changs office?
I recall Chang saying Dr. Skarosa but was it skarosa/cyberman that confronted Clara ?
Still haven’t been able to get my mind to a clear explanation for that one14 November 2014 at 22:57 #35560Ok @Craig- If you want to delete those posts no worries !! I also had no clue about all that stuff
14 November 2014 at 20:23 #35540also in addition: cosmic-hobo [terror of the Autons and a bunch of other BG series 7 and 8}
and Dalek6 that has current AG vids to the DM list above14 November 2014 at 19:35 #35539Thanks to everyone !! I did find a few DM channels that have various episodes so I want to share them
tardismedia2 – -dvlvr – cosmicsurfer1800 – cillbill
There is really a lot of BG Who between them all but not at all complete
Also some audio stories and Sara Jane Adventures14 November 2014 at 16:03 #35532WHi @all – I was wondering if any one knows where to find the BG Who online now? I used to be able
to see every single episode of BG Who on Daily motion on the greendude33 channel [maybe that was 1 of you?]
but alas- tis no more ! Unfortunately he didn’t leave a forwarding address. I was thinking that it
might be nice to revisit some old master episodes after seeing comments about Delgado etc. over
here – so just thought If I inquired here that 1 of you might be able to say?? Thanks !!14 November 2014 at 05:58 #35521Spent over the past hour surfing thru this music thread and discovered some totally super pieces
that I hadn’t known about – made a very interesting and enjoyable evening !
I guess I should thank everyone by contributing a post so as I haven’t seen a lot of jazz and I do
really like jazz I was thinking of Regina Taylor? She is a very talented jazz violinist
and I have a few of her cd’s that are among the many I fall back on when I want to have some
good music in the back round – this is a piece that some one posted of her on You tube14 November 2014 at 01:59 #35514OOPs – I lost track of my typing in that previous post- don’t type and help your kid
do stuff at the same time is the lesson here lol !!14 November 2014 at 01:58 #35513@danmartinuk Hi- I’m a Who-ster from the states so cant make the event but please come back on this thread
and tell us all about it !I imagine you already know this but any time you need some positive reinforcement in regards
to the Doctor Who show this IS really the place ! [But I bet you’ve been reading all the posts]I’ma Who-ster form the States so I
can’t make it ro London on Monday but will you come back and talk to us about that in the
14 November 2014 at 01:14 #35503@scaryb Yes- The graveyard Cybers were refered to as Newborns by the Doctor which reinforces why I think
they aren’t ‘completed” enough to be re-booted into the nethersphere
@bluesqueakpip I have a post a bit way up thread about Osgood- I had this notion that it might be Missy that
wants to bring her back as part of some ‘Master” plan. Missy has so much experience now with resurrecting
both herself and the cybers. It would be really something if she attempts to resurrect a Osgood/Zygon!
Its too soon for me to say why I think it could be a Missy plan other than she actually wants the
Zygon because they can shape shift and this Osgood version has knowledge of how to get into UNIT ? Regarding
the idea that the Zygon wont come back as Osgood if she’s dead- well there are a lot of dead in the
Nethersphere with their minds still intact ??
?14 November 2014 at 00:24 #35496@all Wanted to give a heads up for everyone in the States tomorrow [Friday]the BBCAmerica channel
is running another Doctor Who Marathon again ! So if you want to DVR MattDoc …….13 November 2014 at 23:18 #35490@scaryb I guess I’m differentiating between those Cybermen that we saw in the nethersphere and the
grave yard Cybers – to me the graveyard bunch are [and I cant explain why entirely] as low ranking
privates and the Cybers that were in the nethersphere as higher ranking “chosen” as in the
episodes where we saw Missy choosing certain people, Danny was chosen. So to my mind not all the cybers
do not get a return ticket to the nethersphere13 November 2014 at 22:46 #3548613 November 2014 at 22:45 #35485@ – I’m glad you like my Avatar – Some one but I cant remember who {endless apologies
maybe it was you} said it reminded them of a jelly baby army on the march ! Regarding those
particular Cybermen that blew up the black clouds – I don’t think they may have been from the
Nethersphere – IMO I rather think they all rose up out of their graves in which case I don’t
really think/know they get saving??13 November 2014 at 22:22 #35482Thank you to @phaseshift for the new Master blog and for giving me an idea about resurrecting Osgood
Well maybe it will be similar to how the Simm master and for that matter the Cybermen were resurrected.
With just a little DNA ? The Simm master returned and so did the cyberman so why not “pollinate’
as new Osgood? Could this even be a subtle hint about the “master” plan around Osgood ? Osgood did
tell Missy that she could be useful just before she was killed – and Missy might also decide that
Osgood might have had a point. Plus the Master has all kinds of experience in the resurrection business
now. I just have a hunch about that but I still need to come up with a good enough reason as to why the
Master will want to bring back Osgood – all input is welcome !!!13 November 2014 at 21:42 #35479@spider Regarding the quote — I want to guess that it was a comedian – or maybe a politician [or is that
the same thing these days] ??13 November 2014 at 18:56 #35465@fonsini – If you have a problem with the politics of this show then find a different kind of forum
I agree with @drben and it doesn’t help your case to also ‘channel’ your personal political agenda
btw – maybe you are what is wrong with America today – a blatant lack of inclusiveness and of the
differences of peoples and opinions13 November 2014 at 15:58 #35453@phaseshift – There was definitely an undercurrent jab in that comment [and for my part I took absolutely
no offense in it as a ‘Yank’ girl] GW was one of our worst Presidents IMHO! Im happy to say I never
voted for him and was in fact extremely sad that he got the second term ! However, something
interesting is if you interpret the Galifrey coordinates from Missy as a date then it was the
date that the US Congress voted to give GW war powers to invade Iraq- which will be a difficult
piece of history to swallow for a very long time ! So I think maybe SM wanted to reinforce that
notion in an episode full of hard decisions having to be made?13 November 2014 at 04:12 #35418Saw this and thought the ‘next generation cybermen’ wont need to be inside the rigid shells ?
12 November 2014 at 22:53 #35408@timeloop I like flashbacks as a device cause they can help interpret parts of a story or they
can manipulate how your thinking or get into motive or throw you a fun twist. As this is a
time travel show using flashbacks or even flash forwards seems very appropriate to me
Yes we could also have the extra treat of revisiting other Doctors too !
The flashbacks that I recall would be the 8th Doctor minisode and the Waters of Mars when
10 used his remembrance of what he had read in newspapers about the crew and of course there was
lots of it in the 50th anniversary show. Don’t recall specifically a lot of them in BG Who though12 November 2014 at 15:37 #35389@barnable liked the Danny analysis @apopheniac yours too – [I haven’t spent much time thinking about Danny]
@geoffers thanks for fixing me ! 🙂 🙂 I will particularly watch out for that !
always have a soft spot for certain tragic characters too]
12 November 2014 at 02:09 #35377@ purofilion So yeah –I might re-think using the word easy – Missy has a lot of layers of
complication so I should have used the word rough initially in my original post12 November 2014 at 01:54 #35376oops ! — think that Missy deserves a little compassion/sympathy ?? But she does make that rough
12 November 2014 at 01:49 #35375@ purofilion I guess that is an outstanding question 🙂 So to the extant that Missy has a mental
illness which causes damage every where around her why would I think she deserves sympathy?
Only because people [and aliens] that suffer from mental illness/ are folks that find it very difficult
to differentiate between their ‘identity’ and their illness – Rasilon really didn’t help either with what
he did – Missy cant put distance between the 2 – so instead of feeling vulnerable she does bad things
that land her in hot water – ultimately I think and perhaps also the Doctor may think that12 November 2014 at 00:23 #35370@ Badwulf – I tried to capture the shot but it isn’t cooperating for me 🙁
@ geoffers – yes! The kid put his finger at exactly the right spot so I agree its intentional – thanks!
@ Bluesqueakpip – Missy’s hypnotic talents are very sophisticatedly nuanced !
She is so good at that its hard to see when it happen lol But that talent multiplied by her
encyclopedic knowledge and so on is a great recipe for insanely dangerous or as she admits being “bananas”
So to my mind I find her engaging cause she is a antihero that is easy for me to sympathize with too.11 November 2014 at 20:03 #35355@badwulf I must commend you on your due diligence !!! lol
It is so nice that you live in that neighborhood – I have wonderful memories of my trips there
Still sticking to my idea about smoke coming from the “reflection” tardis [possibly a figure]
Its I think something about the way it seems purposely super imposed on that window pane – maybe ??11 November 2014 at 06:02 #35322@badwulf Maybe its both ? Maybe that’s why there is a reflection of 1 red phone box inside the window
of the other? Btw – I think there may also be a figure in that reflection but its very hard to make out11 November 2014 at 04:58 #35318@badwulf Maybe the different models are perhaps a continuity and /or convenience situation??
11 November 2014 at 04:51 #35317@badwulf – plus the obvious that she chooses a phone box like Doc’s – a tribute to her endless love
for him !11 November 2014 at 04:36 #35315@Janette re: Santa- that’s very relevant point and it does really explains everything 🙂 doesn’t it
11 November 2014 at 04:30 #35314@ geoffers – I have had the same thoughts about how the boy returned in such a perfectly preserved body!
I have been trying to work that out too but so far I got nothing 🙁 So I have to assume as well he must
have some artificial components. In regards to Missy- earlier in the episode when she transported herself
off the plane before it exploded it looked like the same blue contained disappearance which is totally
different from the other reddish explody times when different victims ‘bought it’.
Also, I think she has the red telephone box as a tardis now because why would 1- they keep showing a red telephone box so often? I have been to England many times and I know that there aren’t that many around
anymore and 2 – look at the episode at about 7 1/2 minutes in when the people are standing at the gate
of the cemetery with the black cloud growing over it. There is another red phone box and it has a second
red phone box ‘reflected’ in it. Now it may be an optical illusion but the ‘reflected’ phone box has a
kind of spout on top spewing black smoke! As if its a hint ? As if it is the Missy Tardis? So to me that
means Missy has a Tardis to escape to and does not have to rely on the Nethersphere which btw I think has
been captured by Unit and possibly being powered down ???
Let me know what you think11 November 2014 at 01:18 #35304So a few extra random thoughts —
– Anyone think that St Nick might turn out to be a Time lord ?
– I’d love to see Michele Gomez show up on Sherlock as anything
– Looked up the coordinates that Missy gave the Doc as a possible significant date in history and I came
up with the day that the US Congress gave the President war powers for the Iraq invasion which is what
Kate exactly told the Doctor that the planet Earth had given to him -that seems a bit odd to me11 November 2014 at 00:32 #35301@IAMNotAFishTAmAFreeMan = I peaked at the Guardian, whoviannet and some YT reviews as I
got very curious after having seen a few postings here 🙂@bluesqueakpip – Of course!! the Tardis totally knew who WitS was! wow on that !
10 November 2014 at 23:57 #35296@ DrBen and all- Regarding your comments about the series being wonderful and painful may I suggest
that is exactly why it is such great TV ! I have read some of the comments elsewhere about this
season and I am astounded how many have disliked it- some intensely ! I think because it isn’t
the old school Doctor Who anymore. Also people tend to be risk adverse and SM has really taken
some extreme risks. But I have always seen the show as pushing the risk barrier. SM has evolved it
into something that is really different and is also totally his new-Who!
Some folks thought SM’s Who was sub-par or just lacking or it wasn’t what they tuned in for.
I have been reflecting just to take for an example of how all the villains have changed.
Giving cybermen the ability to reason apart from the collective [although technically that
isn’t really new since it occurred once in the Canary wharf episode] and of course there is
Missy and the good Dalek and the lying liars and so on- its all different now but in really
amazingly creatively realistically constructed ways
SO I agree with you to some extent that I guess many folks feel that they are being too challenged
by the realism of this re-boot when its not supposed to be so serious if its a scifi fantasy show.
I think it can be both10 November 2014 at 21:47 #35280In the scene when the black cloud grows over the gated cemetery and we see a red phone box behind the
people did any one else spot a refection of another red phone box in the mirror-like windows ? It
seemed to me like the second red phone box had a chimney spout on top spewing out that black smoke-cloud
so I am just wondering if that is a clue that the red tardis may indeed be Missy’s tardis?
Also I am wondering about the co ordinates that Missy gave the Doctor – he put 10 0 11 00 02 but was
that the correct interpretation? I listened to her say them again and I’m just not sure if they could
have been entered differently
She also mentioned a Dalek camp in the graveyard? I also have been wondering if there is some Dalek
prison camp that isn’t trapped in the time lock bubble – Could it be located on the North pole of
some planet in time for the Xmas special ?10 November 2014 at 16:52 #35259@ Arbutus – The Doctor spent a extraordinarily small amount of time when he opened the Tardis doors
expecting some evidence of Galifrey. I still think those numbers ‘might’ mean something but he really
didn’t do a thorough check. If he had would he have discovered a ‘crack’ in the neighborhood or
something else?
@brewski As an American who has even posted a few comments about belief/fairy tales etc.
but however not religious in any way [I didn’t inherit those genes]so there fore I do not pray
I make wishes! you might be referring to those wacky red states ? 🙂 Also, I like your catch
regarding the ‘smell’ of Osgood but if she did smell like Zygon wouldn’t the Doctor have smelled that
too ? They were pretty close at the time when he was laying on the ground.
Hi @Barnable- ‘the stories are always bigger on the inside’ Love !9 November 2014 at 23:38 #35210@bluesqueakpip – yes true and it was a festival for the Romans and a bunch of other stuff
plus we saw Santa in the trailer and we just had this episode with the dead being resurrected and in particular Danny saving the planet with the Doctor — and I don’t think SM would want to make a dark Xmas for the kids
either so I will back step from provocative 🙂9 November 2014 at 22:26 #35198sorry- had to leave mid thought – but quickly I have been thinking a lot about all the new versions
of old villains and more on that later- but also a Xmas special conclusion to a season all about
myths and beliefs and we all know what beliefs Xmas is about – and we also have the Afghan boy
resurrected now – so this makes me wonder if the special will use this theme – that would be
provocative9 November 2014 at 22:08 #35194als- It is interesting to me SM’s 2.0 takes on all the new forms of the old villains
9 November 2014 at 21:51 #35192Had to sneak a way to peak here – lol But so worth it ! All of you have had dazzling ideas
Kudos to @mudlark on Clara ‘Impossible’ Girl – Missy WitS paradox !! I read those paragraphs
a LOT! — and to @rob I totally agree on Osgood?Zygon and its a great notion yet I am stuck
still with again why that same conversation regarding her sister? I get the obvious about mean
natured bullying but I think that sister thing is suspiciously odd -ish. Would like to see
a lot of the characters from this season show up for Xmas ! Might just take a peak later on
to see if they have put up any info about the Xmas cast to consider new ‘bonkerizing’9 November 2014 at 18:23 #35163@cadellin — you and I are thinking the same way about the Afghan boy and how that was presented
and what will Clara do about him ? Personally, it has all sorts of ‘oddness’ for me however at
least he doesn’t become a cybezombie . The idea that the dead whether adult or child could get turned
into that seemed a bit rough but I’ve never been a fan of Zombie horror either9 November 2014 at 17:58 #35160@Devilishrobby- I lie your point about the woman in the shop and Clara not recognizing her ! also- I still
think the numbers that Missy gave to the Doctor will have some meaning too
Regarding Osgood- every time we see her they bring up her sister ! – was it a twin sister- a clone sister?9 November 2014 at 17:51 #35159@apopheniac I agree that if the guards behind Missy weren’t there it might have made no difference?
@bluesqueakpip and @ Hudsey I agree that the resurrection of the Afghan Boy had a lot of oddness and
how will Clara handle him? Plus Cyber Danny must still exist in some form to send him back
Also the Nethersphere in the Black Archives is a great notion !
@robert Daller – cyberzombies ! in recent years zombies have become so popular@everyone I am desolate over the end of this series! I have noticed that there has been some negativism
about it however I for 1 thought it was excellent! I think that SM conceived something
that made the series more sophisticated – an appreciation for deeper main character development!9 November 2014 at 04:42 #35104Btw – What has happened to that Galifreyan matrix orb hovering in the mausoleum ?
Cyberman Danny will be back – he is now the leader of a vast army and will probably be called
upon in a future season
I really do realize that the whole Presidential thing is very ridiculous to most Who fans but
I thought the president of Earth/chief executive is well– ok for not being a native born that has
a major aversion to wars -
AuthorPosts


